Corso di laurea

Politics, Philosophy and Public Affairs (PPPA)

Università degli Studi di Milano · 27 materie · 0 file condivisi

Ecco tutti i dettagli sul corso di laurea selezionato. Sul UniDocs troverai gli appunti condivisi dagli altri studenti del tuo corso di laurea, ordinati per materia. Ricordati che per poter visualizzare il materiale devi essere registrato al sito e possedere un numero di crediti sufficiente.

Sfoglia il materiale didattico

Con UniDocs hai l'opportunità di studiare insieme a tutto il tuo corso di laurea. Guadagna subito dei crediti, carica il materiale del tuo ultimo esame!
Più condividi, più tempo avrai per studiare con tutta la community!

Materie del corso

Conflicts, political arrangements and legitimacy 1° anno · 1° semestre · 9 CFU · GSPS-01/A · 0 file

The course intends to prepare students to engage with complex political issues and to enhance their analytical and argumentative skills. These core objectives are pursued by providing students with a comprehensive…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course intends to prepare students to engage with complex political issues and to enhance their analytical and argumentative skills. These core objectives are pursued by providing students with a comprehensive understanding of the key concepts, theories, and debates in political philosophy, which are meant to be useful tools for tackling controversial and publicly debated political questions. More specifically, the course focuses on political conflicts, their sources and their dynamics and on the relevant strategies and arrangements to deal with them. The latter are investigated comparatively in order to enable students to grasp their relative merits and shortcomings. Additionally, the course proposes to train students to apply theoretical categories and frameworks to real-world scenarios for better appreciating their potentiality to make sense of and assess political events and phenomena.

KNOWLEDGE AND UNDERSTANDING:Students are expected to acquire a comprehensive understanding of political conflicts and their relevance for both politics and political philosophy as well as a thorough knowledge of the available options and arrangements to tackle conflicts and their implications. More specifically, students are expected to be able to:- define conflict and identify its primary causes;- critically discuss the link between conflict and politics;- argue for and against the idea that conflict can be politically fruitful;- comparatively assess strategies aimed at supressing conflict with arrangements that are meant to manage - rather than to eliminate - conflict and with arrangements that acknowledge pluralism and its value;- explain what political dissent is and why it characterizes even political societies that do not suppress conflict but rather embrace pluralism;- illustrate the dissenting strategies available to political actors and to assess them by considering both their legitimacy and their effectiveness;- clarify and evaluate the political options for accommodating dissenting positions. APPLYING KNOWLEDGE AND UNDERSTANDING:Students are expected to be able to apply their acquired knowledge and competences to issues animating public debates. To this end, the course offers several occasions for in-depth class discussion, which will provide a suitable space for debating the relevance and import of the philosophical notions and approaches under examination with respect to more concrete matters and questions. Moreover, during classes, the theoretical notions and models under investigations will be illustrated with references to real-world cases of political conflict and their settlement. MAKING JUDGEMENTS:The structure of the course and the selected readings are expected to increase students' propensity for autonomous judgment. The course will address essays providing opposite arguments concerning, for instance, the role of conflict in politics or the strategies to manage it. Students will be therefore introduced to a plurality of perspectives, and this is expected to improve their capacity to adjudicate among competing arguments by autonomously assessing their relative merits and limits. The bulk of the course will consist in the analysis of philosophical arguments - of their premises and their internal structure - and, during both class discussions and presentations, students will be required to critically examine the arguments at stake, thus enhancing their capacity to autonomously judge their validity.COMMUNICATION:Through class discussions and presentations, students are expected to strengthen their communication skills. They will be required to summarize complex arguments in a clear and effective way, and they are expected to actively take part in discussions, by proposing critical insights on the topics under scrutiny and by engaging with arguments proposed by their classmates.

Programma

The course focuses on political conflicts and the relevant strategies and arrangements to deal with them.
After a preliminary discussion about the notion of conflict and its relevance both in politics and political philosophy, the course investigates the sources of conflict, by paying particular attention to conflicts resulting from competing interests, incompatible values and recognition claims. This analysis is meant to provide insights about the specificity of the challenges connected to conflicts triggered by different factors. Yet, independently of its specific causes, conflict can be qualified negatively, due to its disruptive effects. Accordingly, some prominent approaches in political philosophy - most notably Hobbes' - attribute politics with the task of eliminating conflict, and hence, devise political arrangements meant to suppress it. The course addresses similar solutions and offers insights to evaluate them by emphasizing that, although effective in avoiding the negative consequences of conflict, they tend to threaten liberty. Indeed, either liberty is sacrificed for the sake of security or, as in despotic regimes, pacification is imposed through spreading fear, which undermines the possibility of meaningfully exercising liberty.
The course also addresses other prominent traditions in political philosophy - which can be traced back to Machiavelli and Schmitt - that qualify conflict as a distinguishing and ineliminable feature of politics and that invite to question whether conflict can also be conceived as a valuable element to be preserved and valorised. Therefore, the course investigates approaches that emphasize and vindicate the agonistic character of politics, approaches that recognise the inevitability of conflict and propose strategies to cope with it and establish peaceful forms of coexistence despite conflict, and approaches that defend liberal arrangements for their capacity to keep conflict under control while granting ample space to pluralism and its expression.
Even within institutional settings that protects and valorise pluralism, it is unlikely that conflict will be totally absent. Public decisions and authorities are likely to be challenged and contested by dissenting parties, who can voice and promote their claims through a variety of political strategies, ranging from peaceful advocacy and protests to more radical actions, involving disobedience and, at times, violence. Therefore, the course offers an overview of the relevant criteria to assess, on the one hand, the legitimacy and the effectiveness of the strategies employed by dissenting actors and, on the other, the fruitfulness of political solutions that aim at accommodating dissent through toleration or other inclusive arrangements. The course also explores the relevance and import of the right to opt out, intended as an option available to dissenting parties when accommodating solutions are not workable or prove unsatisfying.
Finally, the course discusses whether it would be possible to have a conflict-free society, namely, a society in which conflict is absent, not because it is actively suppressed, but because it does not arise thanks to individual motivations and commitment to live harmoniously, or to the lack of triggering factors, such as scarcity of resources, endorsement of incompatible values or of identity claims that cannot be reconciled. Once the conditions making a similar society possible are clarified, the course offers insights to assess whether it would be desirable or not, whether it would amount to a utopian or a dystopian society, thus further enlightening the reasons why conflict can be alternatively qualified as positive or negative as well as the costs and the benefits of doing away with conflict.
The mentioned questions and issues will be introduced through classes organized around the following topics and subtopics:
CONFLICTS AND ITS SOURCES

  • Competing interests
  • Values and recognition
    WITHOUT CONFLICT
  • The Leviathan's authority. Security before liberty
  • Despotism and regimes of fear: Hannah Arendt and Judith Shklar
    CONFLICT AND POLITICS
  • Politics as conflict
  • Conflict as a value?
  • Settling conflicts: goals and procedures
    ARBITRATION
  • Human nature before politics. Political judgement and legitimate authority in John Locke
    LIBERAL IDEALS AND PLURALISM
  • Mill and Berlin. Against the tyranny of the majority and monism
  • Rawls. Pluralism and the priority of the right over the good
    ACTING CONFLICT
  • Political dissent
  • Violence and politics
  • Civil, uncivil and radical actions
    THE POLITICAL STRATEGY OF TOLERATION
  • Classical and multicultural toleration
    THE MIGRANTS' SOCIETY
  • The limits of traditional inclusion and the right to leave
    CONFLICT VS. SOCIAL HARMONY
  • Conflict-less societies: utopia or dystopia?
    Classes devoted to introducing the listed topics are accompanied by classes dedicated to the discussion of the connected readings. Moreover, the final part of the course is entirely devoted to the analysis of real-world scenarios that provide instances of how conflicts emerge and are tackled in politics, of how political actors express their dissent or advance their conflicting claims and of how and through which political solutions or arrangements similar claims are addressed and managed. The critical discussion of the selected cases is meant to show how theoretical categories and analytical frames can be fruitfully employed make sense of and to assess concrete political events and phenomena.
    The complete syllabus of the course, completed with precise indications about the dates, will be available on the course's myAriel website before classes start.

Modalità d'esame

The exam structure is different for: 1. Attending students, and 2. Non-attending students.
1. ATTENDING STUDENTS
Attending students are expected to regularly attend classes and actively participate in discussions and other in-class activities.
More specifically, attending students are required to:

  • attend at least 75% of each of the following course activities: introductory classes, class discussions, and case presentation sessions;
  • before each class devoted to discussion, deliver remarks on the readings at stake by completing the relative online "Questions and comments form";
  • sit for the midterm written test;
  • select two cases on which they will work with their teams for the case presentations to be delivered in class;
  • take an active part in the preparation of the case presentations and in the following discussions;
  • deliver a "Case report" at the end of the course.
    The deadline for each assignment, the online forms, and the dates of the midterm written test and the presentations will be available on the course's myAriel website before classes start.
    Please note: The listed requirements and the connected deadlines admit no exceptions: students who fail to comply with any of them will have to take the exam following the indications for non-attending students.
    For students fulfilling all the mentioned requirements, final grades (out of thirty) result from the weighted mean between their grades for:
  • the midterm written test (30%) [see section 1.1];
  • participation in the two discussions following their teams' presentations (40% in total, 20% each) [see section 1.2];
  • the Case report (30%) [see section 1.3].
    Please note: The mean is rounded up from .5 upwards; 30 cum laude equals 33, and for the overall evaluation, it is obtained with a minimum score of 31.5.
    Final grades for attending students will be published anonymously (i.e. with matriculation numbers only) on the course's myAriel website prior to official registration.
    1.1 MIDTERM WRITTEN TEST
    The test comprises open questions meant to verify the students' knowledge and understanding of the readings included in the exam program as well as of the topics addressed during classes and discussions. The written test also intends to ascertain the students' capacity to appropriately summarize and frame their acquired knowledge to answer specific questions rigorously and without digressions. Moreover, the written test intends to verify the students' capacity to establish meaningful connections among the various topics addressed in the exam materials, to grasp the implications of the relevant arguments and to assess, also in a comparative way, the adequacy of the different philosophical approaches illustrated in the reading assignments and discussed during classes.
    The written tests will be marked with grades out of thirty, resulting from the separate evaluation of each provided answer. The evaluation is based on the pertinence, completeness and correctness of the answers' content, and it also considers their clarity and level of detail as well as the coherence, relevance and originality of the arguments proposed by the students [see section 3]. The grade for the written test is determined by the mean between the grades attributed to each answer. Please note: The mean is rounded up from .5 upwards, and 30 cum laude equals 33, and in the evaluation of the written test, it is obtained with a minimum score of 31.5.
    The results of the midterm written test will be notified to students through the course's myAriel website.
    1.2 CASE PRESENTATION AND DISCUSSION
    The final part of the course focuses on real-world cases meant to provide instances of how conflicts emerge and are tackled in politics. Students will be required to select two of the proposed cases, and they will work in teams, with each team responsible for preparing and delivering an in-class presentation of one case.
    Case presentations are expected to provide:
  • a summary of the relevant facts and (if appropriate) insights for contextualizing the case;
  • indications on the categories relevant to account for or to interpret the case (if appropriate, with reference to the theoretical categories and approaches addressed during classes);
  • an evaluative analysis of the strategies endorsed by the actors involved and/or of the political solutions and arrangements at stake.
    More details on how to prepare the presentation will be provided during classes and on the course's myAriel website.
    Each team presentation will need to respect specific time constraints and will be followed by a general discussion on the case at hand.
    The members of the presenting team will be assessed individually based on their participation in the discussion, subject to time constraints too. More precisely, students will be evaluated based on their capacity to:
  • appropriately intervene in the discussion by proposing issues to be dealt with (up to 10 points);
  • address questions and comments by students in the audience (up to 10 points);
  • defend their proposed interpretation and evaluation of the case (up to 10 points);
  • respect time constraints and efficiently use the time at their disposal (up to 3 points).
    The grade (out of thirty) for the participation in the case discussion is determined by the sum of the scores obtained for each of the mentioned aspects. 30 cum laude is obtained with a minimum score of 31.
    The grades for participation in case discussion will be published on the course's myAriel website right after the end of classes.
    1.3 CASE REPORT
    The Case report is a short document to be prepared by each student individually. It is aimed at presenting and discussing one of the cases proposed for the case presentations. Please note: Students are required to select a case not previously addressed with their teams, and they are allowed to propose a case of their choice, which needs to be agreed upon in advance with one of the instructors of the course.
    The Case report should be no longer than 15.000 characters (titles, notes, spaces, etc. included - bibliography not included) and it is expected to provide:
  • a summary of the relevant facts and (if appropriate) insights to contextualize the case;
  • indications on the categories relevant to account for or to interpret the case (if appropriate, with reference to the theoretical categories and approaches addressed during classes);
  • an evaluative analysis of the strategies endorsed by the actors involved and/or of the political solutions and arrangements at stake.
    More details on how to write the Case report will be offered during classes and on the course's myAriel website.
    The Case report will be assessed considering the:
  • relevance and completeness of the factual information provided about the case (up to 8 points);
  • appropriateness and insightfulness of the proposed interpretation (up to 8 points);
  • consistency, relevance and originality of the arguments proposed to evaluate the decisions and the strategies endorsed by the actors involved and/or to assess the political solutions and arrangements at stake (up to 8 points);
  • overall structure of the report (up to 6 points);
  • relevance of the sources and materials referred to in the report, and the appropriateness of their use (up to 3 points).
    The overall grade (out of thirty) for the case report is determined by the sum of the scores obtained for each of the mentioned aspects. 30 cum laude is obtained with a minimum score of 31.
    The results for the case report will be published on the course's myAriel website.
    2. NON-ATTENDING STUDENTS
    For non-attending students, the exam consists of:
  • preparing a "Case report" to be submitted through the course's myAriel website within the specified deadline for the selected exam session (see section 2.1);
  • sitting for a written test (see section 2.2).
    Please note:
  • Students who fail to submit the case report within the relevant deadline will not have the hance to sit for the written test; Case reports submitted by students who do no sit for the written test will not be assessed.
  • The Case Report and the written test are evaluated separately, as they are meant to ascertain the acquisition of different competences and capacities. The exam is considered passed only if both the written test and the Case Report are graded as sufficient.
  • If the written test is failed, the submitted Case Report will not be graded. For the next exam session, students are free to re-submit the same Case Report or submit a new one.
  • If the exam is failed because the Case Report is graded as insufficient, or if students reject the final grade, they will be required to prepare a new Case Report on a different case for the next exam session.
    The final grade results from the mean between the grade for the Case Report and the grade for the written test. Please note: The mean is rounded up from .5 upwards, and 30 cum laude equals 33 and, in the overall evaluation, it is obtained with a minimum score of 31.5.
    Final grades for non-attending students will be published anonymously (with matriculation numbers only) on the course's myAriel website prior to official registration.
    2.1 CASE REPORT
    The Case report is a short document aimed at presenting and discussing one of cases listed on the course's myAriel website. The proposed cases are drawn from real-world scenarios that provide instances of how conflicts emerge and are tackled in politics.
    The Case report should be no longer than 15.000 characters (titles, notes, spaces, etc. included - bibliography not included) and it is meant to provide:
  • a summary of the relevant facts and (if appropriate) insights to contextualize the case;
  • indications on the categories relevant to account for or to interpret the case (if appropriate, with reference to the theoretical categories and approaches addressed in the readings);
  • an evaluative analysis of the strategies endorsed by the actors involved and/or of the political solutions and arrangements at stake.
    More details on how to write the Case report will be offered on the course's myAriel website.
    The Case report will be assessed considering the:
  • relevance and completeness of the factual information provided about the case (up to 8 points);
  • appropriateness and insightfulness of the proposed interpretation (up to 8 points);
  • consistency, relevance and originality of the arguments proposed to evaluate the decisions and the strategies endorsed by the actors involved and/or to assess the political solutions and arrangements at stake (up to 8 points);
  • overall structure of the report (up to 6 points);
  • relevance of the sources and materials referred to in the report, and the appropriateness of their use (up to 3 points).
    The overall grade (out of thirty) for the case report is determined by the sum of the scores obtained for each of the mentioned aspects. 30 cum laude is obtained with a minimum score of 31.
    2.2 WRITTEN TEST
    The test comprises open questions meant to verify the students' knowledge and understanding of the readings included in the exam program. The written test also intends to ascertain the students' capacity to appropriately summarize and frame their acquired knowledge to answer specific questions rigorously and without digressions. Moreover, the written test aims at verifying the students' capacity to establish meaningful connections among the various topics addressed in the exam materials, to grasp the implications of the relevant arguments and to assess, also in a comparative way, the adequacy of the different philosophical approaches illustrated in the reading assignments.
    The written tests will be marked with grades out of thirty, resulting from the separate evaluation of each provided answer. The evaluation is based on the pertinence, completeness and correctness of the answers' content, and it also considers the their clarity and level of detail as well as the coherence, relevance and originality of the arguments proposed by the students [see section 3]. The overall grade for the written test is determined by the mean of the grades attributed to each answer. Please note: The mean is rounded up from .5 upwards, and 30 cum laude equals 33 and it is obtained with a minimum score of 31.5.
    3. GRADES SCALE FOR WRITTEN TESTS' ANSWERS
    The following indications apply to the midterm written test for attending students and to the written test for non-non attending students.
    Each answer is assessed individually, and a grade out of thirty is assigned according to the following criteria:
  • 10-14: missing or non-pertinent answers, or poorly developed answers showing little or no understanding of the question;
  • 15-17: either incomplete answers (that address only part of the question, even if well-developed), or complete answers that are mostly incorrect or show major misunderstandings;
  • 18-20: pertinent, complete, and mostly correct answers, affected by serious inaccuracies, excessive irrelevant content, or significant weaknesses in clarity, detail, contextualization, or argumentative structure;
  • 21-23: pertinent, complete, and mostly correct answers containing inaccuracies or occasional irrelevancies, and affected by moderate shortcomings in clarity, detail, contextualization, or argumentative structure;
  • 24-26: pertinent, complete, and correct answers that are generally clear, properly detailed, contextualized, and argued, with only minor flaws;
  • 27-29: pertinent, complete, and correct answers that are definitely clear, accurate, well detailed and contextualized, supported by well-structured arguments and showing some personal re-elaboration of the topic;
  • 30: pertinent, correct, exhaustive, and well-argued answers that are definitely clear, well detailed and contextualized, supported by well-structured arguments, and enriched with critical and original insights;
  • 30 cum laude: pertinent, correct, exhaustive and well-argued answers that are definitely clear, well detailed and contextualized, and that demonstrate thorough mastery of the topic and the ability to rigorously and originally rework and articulate acquired knowledge.

Testi di riferimento

The exam material is different for: 1. Attending students, and 2. Non-attending students.
1. ATTENDING STUDENTS
For attending students, the exam material is organized with reference to the topics included in the syllabus.
CONFLITCTS AND ITS SOURCES

  • Lukes, S. (1989), "Making sense of moral conflict", in N. L. Rosenblum (ed.), Liberalism and the moral life, Harvard University Press, pp. 127-142.
  • Berlin, I. (2002), Liberty, Oxford University Press: "Introduction", § II 'Positive versus negative liberty', pp. 41-45; "Two concepts of liberty", § VIII 'The one and the many', pp. 212-217.
  • Gray, J. (1998), "Where pluralists and liberals part company", International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 6(1): 17-36.
  • Taylor, C. (1992), "The politics of recognition", in A. Gutman (ed.), Multiculturalism. Examining the politics of recognition, Princeton University Press, pp. 25-73.
    WITHOUT CONFLICT
  • Hobbes, T. [1651], Leviathan, chap. 14, 17, 21.
  • Hobbes, T. [1642], De Cive, chap. 5.
  • Arendt, H. (1953), "Ideology and Terror", Review of Politics, 15(3), 303-327.
  • Arendt, H. (1950), "Social Science Techniques and the Study of Concentration Camps", Jewish social studies, 12(1), 49-64.
  • Arendt, H. (1951, 1976), The Origins of Totalitarianism, pp. 464-482.
  • Shklar, J. (1987), Montesquieu, chap. 1.
  • Shklar, J. (1989), "Liberalism of Fear", in Liberalism and the Moral Life, ed. Nancy L. Rosenblum, pp. 21-38.
    CONFLICTS AND POLITICS
  • Marx, K. and Engels, F. (1848), The Communist Manifesto, excerpts, in J. Elster [ed.] (1986), Karl Marx. A reader, Cambridge University Press: Chap. 19 "Class Consciousness and Class Struggle", pp. 225-235.
  • Schmitt, C. (1932), The concept of the political: Excerpts
  • Machiavelli, N. (1531), Discourses on the first ten books of Titus Livy: Book I, Chapters 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 37.
  • Machiavelli, N. (1525), Florentine Histories. Newly Translated Edition, Princeton University Press [1990]: Book III, Chapter 1, pp. 105-106.
  • Mouffe, C. (2013), Agonistics. Thinking the world politically, Verso: Chap. 1 "What Is Agonistic Politics?", pp. 1-6.
  • Hampshire, S. (1996), "Justice is conflict: The soul and the city", Tanner lectures on human values.
  • Mansbridge, J. et al. (2010), "The place of self‐interest and the role of power in deliberative democracy", Journal of Political Philosophy, 18(1): 64-100.
    ARBITRATION
    Locke, J. [1690], Second Treatise of Government, chap. I, II, III, VII §77, VIII §95-99.119-122.
    LIBERAL IDEALS AND PLURALISM
  • Mill, J. S. [1859], On Liberty, chap. 1, 3.
  • Berlin, I. (2002), Freedom and its Betrayal, chap. "Rousseau".
  • Rawls, J. (1988), "The Priority of Right and Ideas of the Good", Philosophy & Public Affairs, 17(4), 251-276.
    ACTING CONFLICT
  • Milligan, T. (2022), "The very idea of dissent", in The ethics of political dissent, Routledge, pp. 31-54
  • Euchner, C. (2018), "Tactics of activists", in Extraordinary politics: How protest and dissent are changing American democracy. Routledge.
  • Arendt, H. (1970), On violence, Harcourt - Excerpts.
  • Bufacchi, V. (2005), "Two concepts of violence", Political studies review, 3(2), 193-204.
  • Delmas, C. (2018), A duty to resist: When disobedience should be uncivil, Oxford University Press: Chap. 1 "Principled disobedience", § 'A Matrix of Resistance', pp. 39-46; Chap. 2 "In defense of uncivil disobedience", pp. 47-71.
  • Akbar, A. A. (2020), "The Radical Possibilities of Protest", in M. Schwartzberg (ed.), Protest and Dissent: NOMOS LXII (Vol. 3), New York University Press, pp. 64-80.
    THE POLITICAL STRATEGY OF TOLERATION
  • Locke, J. [1689], A Letter Concerning Toleration.
  • Galeotti, A. E. (2002), Toleration as Recognition, chap. 2.
    THE MIGRANTS' SOCIETY
    Ottonelli, V.-Torresi, T. (2022), The Right not to Stay, chap. 1-2.
    POLITICS WITHOUT CONFLICT
  • Cohen, G.A. (2008), Why not Socialism?, Princeton University Press: Chap. 1 "The camping trip", pp. 3-45.
  • Nozick, R. (1974), Anarchy, State and Utopia, Basic Books: Chap. 10 "A Framework for Utopia", pp. 297-334.
    For attending students, the exam materials for the midterm written test includes all the readings listed above plus the slides with the lecture notes, which will be available on the course's myAriel website.
    Please note: Readings which are difficult to find will be available on the course's myAriel website, where students will also find indications about the relevant excerpts from the listed readings.
    2. NON-ATTENDING STUDENTS
    To familiarize with the theoretical approaches and categories relevant to work on their case report and to sit for the written test, non-attending students are expected to prepare the following list of readings:
  • Lukes, S. (1989), "Making sense of moral conflict", in N.L. Rosenblum (ed.), Liberalism and the moral life, Harvard University Press, pp. 127-142.
  • Ceva, E. (2012), "Pluralism", in A. Besussi (ed.), A companion to political philosophy. Methods, tools, topics, Ashgate, pp. 195-205.
  • Berlin, I. (2002), Liberty, Oxford University Press: "Introduction", § II 'Positive versus negative liberty', pp. 41-45; "Two concepts of liberty", § VIII 'The one and the many', pp. 212-217.
  • Gray, J. (1998), "Where pluralists and liberals part company", International Journal of Philosophical Studies, 6(1): 17-36.
  • Taylor, C. (1992), "The politics of recognition", in A. Gutman (ed.), Multiculturalism. Examining the politics of recognition, Princeton University Press, pp. 25-73.
  • Marx, K. and Engels, F. (1848), The Communist Manifesto, excerpts, in J. Elster [ed.] (1986), Karl Marx. A reader, Cambridge University Press: Chap. 19 "Class Consciousness and Class Struggle", pp. 225-235.
  • Schmitt, C. (1932), The concept of the political - excerpts
  • Machiavelli, N. (1531), Discourses on the first ten books of Titus Livy: Book I, Chapters 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 37.
  • Machiavelli, N. (1525), Florentine Histories. Newly Translated Edition, Princeton University Press [1990]: Book III, Chapter 1, pp. 105-106.
  • Mouffe, C. (2013), Agonistics. Thinking the world politically, Verso: Chap. 1 "What Is Agonistic Politics?", pp. 1-6.
  • Milligan, T. (2022), "The very idea of dissent", in The ethics of political dissent, Routledge, pp. 31-54.
  • Euchner, C. (2018), Extraordinary politics: How protest and dissent are changing American democracy. Routledge: Chap. 6 "Tactics of activists".
  • Toros, H. (2016). "From dissent to revolution: politics and violence", in M. Breen-Smyth (ed.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Political Violence, Routledge, pp. 119-136.
  • Bufacchi, V. (2007), Violence and social justice, Springer: Chap. 1 "The concept of violence", pp. 11-28; Chap. 2 "Violence and integrity", pp. 29-47; Chap. 5 "Four faces of violence" pp. 88-109.
  • Arendt, H. (1970), On violence, Harcourt: Excerpts.
  • Delmas, C. (2018), A duty to resist: When disobedience should be uncivil, Oxford University Press: Chap. 1 "Principled disobedience", § 'A Matrix of Resistance', pp. 39-46; Chap. 2 "In defense of uncivil disobedience", pp. 47-71.
  • Celikates, R. (2016), "Democratizing civil disobedience", Philosophy & Social Criticism, 42(10), 982-994.
  • Akbar, A. A. (2020), "The Radical Possibilities of Protest", in M. Schwartzberg (ed.), Protest and Dissent: NOMOS LXII (Vol. 3). NYU Press, pp. 64-80.
  • Hobbes, T. [1651], Leviathan, chap. 14, 17, 21.
  • Hobbes, T. [1642], De Cive, chap. 5.
  • Arendt, H. (1953), "Ideology and Terror", Review of Politics, 15(3), 303-327.
  • Arendt, H. (1950), "Social Science Techniques and the Study of Concentration Camps", Jewish social studies, 12(1), 49-64.
  • Arendt, H. (1951, 1976), The Origins of Totalitarianism, pp. 464-482.
  • Shklar, J. (1987), Montesquieu, chap. 1.
  • Shklar, J. (1989), "Liberalism of Fear", in Liberalism and the Moral Life, ed. Nancy L. Rosenblum, pp. 21-38.
  • Locke, J. [1690], Second Treatise of Government, chap. I, II, III, VII §77, VIII §95-99.119-122.
  • Mill, J. S. [1859], On Liberty, chap. 1, 3.
  • Berlin, I. (2002), Freedom and its Betrayal, chap. "Rousseau".
  • Rawls, J. (1988), "The Priority of Right and Ideas of the Good", Philosophy & Public Affairs, 17(4), 251-276.
  • Locke, J. [1689], A Letter Concerning Toleration.
  • Galeotti, A. E. (2002), Toleration as Recognition, chap. 2.
  • Ottonelli, V.-Torresi, T. (2022), The Right not to Stay, chap. 1-2.
    Please note: Readings which are difficult to find will be available on the course's myAriel website, where students will also find indications about the relevant excerpts from the listed readings.

Codice insegnamento conflicts-political-arrangements-and-legitimacy-0

Critical thinking and argumentation 1° anno · 3 CFU · PHIL-02/A · 0 file

By the end of the course, students are expected to:1. Clearly understand and explain the concepts of logical arguments and fallacies.2. Identify and analyze formal and informal logical fallacies in various texts.3.…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

By the end of the course, students are expected to:1. Clearly understand and explain the concepts of logical arguments and fallacies.2. Identify and analyze formal and informal logical fallacies in various texts.3. Recognize cognitive biases and understand their impact on reasoning and decision-making.4. Apply strategies to reduce noise and improve the quality of judgments and decisions.5. Develop critical thinking skills that enable them to challenge assumptions and approach complex issues independently.

● Analytical Skills: Enhance your ability to critically assess arguments and evidence.● Practical Application: Apply theoretical knowledge through practical exercises and real-world examples.● Independent Thinking: Gain the confidence to challenge assumptions and think independently on important issues.

Programma

The class material is based on these texts:
Bowell, Tracy, and Gary Kemp. Critical thinking: A concise guide. Routledge, 2014. [Chapter 1-7]
Fosl, Peter S., and Julian Baggini. The philosopher's toolkit: a compendium of philosophical concepts and methods. John Wiley & Sons, 2020. [Chapters 1-3]
McKay, Thomas (2000), Reasons, Explanations and Decisions: Guidelines for Critical Thinking. Wadsworth. [Chapters 1-5, 8] (Hard to find: the material provided in the slides will be enough)
Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter. Think again: how to reason and argue. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018. [Chapters 5-10]
Slides and exercises are a crucial part of the program.

Modalità d'esame

Assessment is conducted through two partial assessments, held on two dates announced during the course. The partial assessments consist of exercises similar to those practiced together in class and assigned individually as weekly homework, which is subsequently reviewed in class.
Students who pass both partial assessments have completed the assessment and do NOT need to take the final exam. Students who do not pass one or both partial assessments, or who are unable to attend them, may take the final exam instead, covering the entire course content. This option is intended as a last resort and is therefore not recommended unless necessary.
The final assessment consists of an in-person written exam with 5 or 6 exercises covering the main topics of the course. The exercises are similar to those practiced together in class and to those assigned individually as weekly homework and subsequently reviewed in class.
Both the partial assessments and the final exam are assessed on a pass/fail basis. In either case, the assessment is considered passed if at least three-fifths (3/5) of the answers are correct. For this reason, regular and extensive practice with the exercises is typically the best way to prepare for the assessment and successfully pass the exam.

Testi di riferimento

Bowell, Tracy, and Gary Kemp. Critical thinking: A concise guide. Routledge, 2014.
Fosl, Peter S., and Julian Baggini. The philosopher's toolkit: a compendium of philosophical concepts and methods. John Wiley & Sons, 2020.
Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter. Think again: how to reason and argue. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018.

Codice insegnamento critical-thinking-and-argumentation

Economy and society: past, present and perspectives 1° anno · 2° semestre · 6 CFU · GSPS-02/A · 0 file

Learning objectives are coherent with the general objectives of the degree course (applied, specialized knowledge) and with the formation of specific professional figures required by the job opportunities of to-day labor…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

Learning objectives are coherent with the general objectives of the degree course (applied, specialized knowledge) and with the formation of specific professional figures required by the job opportunities of to-day labor market The course will foster the active involvement of students in the learning process through plenary discussions and the writing of papers on key topics, as swell as the coordination and interaction with other teachers. The Economy and Society course aims at developing the basic critical skills which are necessary to appraise the relationships between economy and society and to analyse the great transition taking place in to-day world, i.e. the deep, manyfold transformation in labor, enterprise, markets, institutions and social relations, that is induced by the scientific-technological revolution and global modernization. This critical analysis is made with regard to both the theories of classical social science thinkers and the empirical research of contemporary scholars. More specifically, the concepts, methods and theoretical models of Economic Sociology and Political Economy are applied to the study of processes of production, distribution, exchange and consumption, providing an alternative approach to the hegemonic neo-liberal paradigm in contemporary economics.

The expected learning outcome of the Economy and Society course is synthetically that students obtain the knowledge and expertise necessary to understand and critically discuss public issues in political institutions, economic relations, media, scientific and technological research and to act in the public sphere in order to orient with the policy choices of decision makers evidence-based knowledge. Economy and Society, together with the other courses of the 1st year, will focus on the analysis ofkey changes in the social and economic scenario, the interplay between global networks and local identities, the strategy and organization of key actors, the main political and institutional responses to transformation and crisis , the conflicts of interests and moral dilemmas underlying collective choices, and the middle and long-term implications of these choices.

Programma

The expected learning outcome of the Economy and Society course is synthetically that students obtain the knowledge and expertise necessary to understand and critically discuss public issues in political institutions, economic relations, media, scientific and technological research and to act in the public sphere in order to orient with the policy choices of decision makers evidence-based knowledge. Economy and Society, together with the other courses of the 1st year, will focus on the analysis ofkey changes in the social and economic scenario, the interplay between global networks and local identities, the strategy and organization of key actors, the main political and institutional responses to transformation and crisis , the conflicts of interests and moral dilemmas underlying collective choices, and the middle and long-term implications of these choices.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento economy-and-society-past-present-and-perspectives

Empirical research in political sciences 1° anno · 2° semestre · 3 CFU · GSPS-02/A · 0 file

The Empirical Research in Political Science (ERiPS) course contributes to PPPA's goals of familiarizing students with the research methods used to study and explain political and social processes, as well as the…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The Empirical Research in Political Science (ERiPS) course contributes to PPPA's goals of familiarizing students with the research methods used to study and explain political and social processes, as well as the philosophical methods of conceptual, logical, and argumentative analysis and critical evaluation.ERiPS introduces students to the use of empirics to respond to foundational research questions — "what," "why," "how," and "will"—about political phenomena. Students will examine key meth-odological approaches in political science —descriptive, causal and explanatory, and predictive—focusing on their epistemological assumptions, trade-offs, and specific translation into actual strategies. Students will grow essential reflexive competencies and analytical mindsets for more applied methodological modules. Therefore, ERiPS examines strategies in an exploratory manner rather than for technical mastery.

KNOWLEDGE AND UNDERSTANDING:Students are expected to acquire a comprehensive understanding of the foundations underpinning empirical political science research and their implications for descriptive, explanatory, and predictive inquiry. More specifically, students are expected to be able to:- Define and deconstruct political concepts, identifying dimensions, attributes, and their relationships while avoiding concept stretching and misformation;- Recognize different conceptions of causality and their epistemological implications;- Distinguish between theory-driven strategies and design-based strategies for causal inference;- Appreciate commonalities and differences between explanatory and predictive goals in political science research and their respective logics;- Analyze how different epistemological traditions shape methodological choices;- Articulate the trade-offs between internal validity, external validity, and theoretical relevance across different research designs;- Consider nesting approaches for robust causal inference.APPLYING KNOWLEDGE AND UNDERSTANDING:Students are expected to apply their acquired methodological knowledge through progressive portfolio assignments that mirror real research practice.Through brief assignments, method journal entries, and a final research proposal memo, students will practice conceptualizing political phenomena, selecting appropriate causal strategies, and developing coherent empirical designs.Moreover, during class discussions of published contributions, students will learn to recognize how epistemological choices shape research outcomes and assess the appropriateness of different strategies for specific political questions.MAKING JUDGMENTS:The portfolio-based structure and comparative analysis of readings are designed to enhance students' capacity for autonomous methodological reasoning. The course systematically presents competing approaches—from different conceptualization strategies to alternative causal inference methods—requiring students to:- Assess the coherence between logical assumptions, methodological choices, and empirical claims in research;- Evaluate the relative merits of theory-driven versus design-based causal strategies for specific research questions;- Critically examine the assumptions underlying different predictive strategies and their suitability for political analysis;- Judge independently whether nested designs offer advantages over single-method approaches for particular inquiries;- Develop criteria for selecting among competing methodological options based on research goals and epistemological commitments.Through iterative assignments and reflective journal entries, students will cultivate the critical judgment necessary for coherent research design. COMMUNICATION:Through method journal entries, research briefs, and class discussions, students develop their ability to articulate complex methodological reasoning with precision and clarity. The course will require them to:- Synthesize logical and methodological concepts in concise written formats that demonstrate their intuition and precision;- Present comparative assessments of methodological strategies that balance technical accuracy with accessibility;- Construct persuasive justifications for methodological choices that connect abstract principles to concrete research applications;- Engage constructively in group discussions about research design trade-offs, communicating complex ideas to peers;- Demonstrate proficiency with methodological vocabulary while maintaining clarity for a broader academic audience.The final colloquium provides an additional opportunity to refine communication skills through individual discussion of portfolio work. LEARNING SKILLS:Students will develop key competencies that will ease their future engagement with advanced technical modules and independent research. The exploratory, portfolio-based approach fosters:- Self-directed learning capabilities for navigating methodological literature across philosophical traditions and empirical strategies;- Iterative refinement skills through progressive assignments that build from conceptualization through causal analysis to research design;- Capacity to integrate descriptive, explanatory, and predictive logics into coherent research proposals;- Awareness of one's epistemological assumptions and their influence on methodological choices throughout the research process;- Ability to identify appropriate methodological resources for specific research challenges and to assess their philosophical compatibility;- Skills in connecting abstract debates about causation, measurement, and prediction to practical research decisions;- Readiness to engage with specific methods courses (quantitative, qualitative, or mixed) based on solid philosophical and conceptual foundations.These competencies, consolidated through the capstone research proposal memo, prepare stu-dents for thesis-level empirical research and lifelong methodological learning.

Programma

Session 01. Introduction
This opening session introduces students to the course and establishes the foundational questions that will guide our exploration of empirical research methods. After brief introductions, we will engage in a critical debate about the scientific status of political science, exploring key tensions surrounding the nature of valid knowledge. The session concludes with an overview of the course structure, learning objectives, and available resources.
At the end of this session, students will be able to identify foundational epistemological questions in political science, differentiate between paradigmatic approaches to empirical inquiry, and reflect critically on the nature of valid knowledge in the discipline. They will also gain an understanding of the structure and goals of the course, setting the basis for self-directed learning.
Backing materials
Mahoney J, Goertz G. (2006). A tale of two cultures: contrasting quantitative and qualitative research. Political Analysis, 14(3), 227-249. https://doi.org/10.1093/pan/mpj017
Walker, T. C. (2010). The perils of paradigm mentalities: revisiting Kuhn, Lakatos, and Popper. Perspectives on Politics, 8(2), 433-451. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1537592710001180
Van Bouwel, J. (2025). Dimensions of the methodological individualism/holism debate. In Y. Shan (Ed.), History and Philosophy of the Social Sciences. Springer. https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/23605
Module A. Description
This module introduces the foundational elements of descriptive research in political science. Students will learn how to develop clear conceptual frameworks, create valid measurements, and establish reliable indicators for political phenomena. The emphasis is on building analytical tools for systematic description and comparison in political research.
Session 02. Frameworks
This session examines the essential role of descriptive research in political science. Students will be introduced to the reasons why description is a critical component of research. We will analyze Sartori's warnings about concept misformation and stretching and learn Goertz's framework for understanding concept structure.
At the end of this session, students will understand the central role of description in empirical research and learn to assess the integrity of conceptual frameworks. They will also become familiar with criteria to construct and evaluate social science concepts, developing skills essential for autonomous and cumulative learning.
Core readings
Sartori, G. (1970). Concept misformation in comparative politics. American Political Science Review, 64(4), 1033-1053. https://doi.org/1033-1053. 10.2307/1958356
Goertz, G. (2020). Concept structure: aggregation and substitutability. In Id. Social science concepts and measurement. Princeton University Press, Ch.6.
Further readings
Gerring J. (2012). Mere description. British Journal of Political Science, 42(4), 721-746. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007123412000130
Adcock, R., & Collier, D. (2001). Measurement validity: a shared standard for qualitative and quantitative research. American Political Science Review, 95(3), 529-546. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055401003100
Damonte, A., & Bazzan, G. (2024). Rules as data. Regulation & Governance, 18(3), 657-673. https://doi.org/10.1111/rego.12582
Session 03. Illustrations
Building on the conceptual foundations from Session 02, this session focuses on translating concepts into measurable indicators. Through guided discussions of the assigned readings, student groups will consider the possible shapes of concepts and the consequences of different operationalizations.
Discussion readings
Munck, G. L., & Verkuilen, J. (2002). Conceptualizing and measuring democracy: evaluating alternative indices. Comparative Political Studies, 35(1), 5-34. https://doi.org/10.1177/001041400203500101
Little, A. T., & Meng, A. (2024). Measuring democratic backsliding. PS: Political Science & Politics, 57(2), 149-161. https://doi.org/10.1017/S104909652300063X
Knutsen, C. H., Marquardt, K. L., Seim, B., Coppedge, M., Edgell, A. B., Medzihorsky, J., Lindberg, S. I. (2024). Conceptual and measurement issues in assessing democratic backsliding. PS: Political Science & Politics, 57(2), 162-177. https://doi.org/10.1017/S104909652300077X
Claassen, C., Ackermann, K., Bertsou, E., Borba, L., Carlin, R. E., Cavari, A., Dahlum, S., Gherghina, S., Hawkins, D., Lelkes, Y., Magalhães, P. C., Mattes, R., Meijers, M. J., Neundorf, A., Oross, D., Öztürk, A., Sarsfield, R., Self, D., Stanley, B., Zechmeister, E. J. (2024). Conceptualizing and measuring support for democracy: a new approach. Comparative Political Studies, 58(6), 1171-1198. https://doi.org/10.1177/00104140241259458
Portfolio Deliverable I: Brief
After the session, students choose a political concept of their interest and submit an original brief (max. 750 words, verified references excluded) that:
1. clearly defines the chosen concept based on the literature,
2. deconstructs it into relevant dimensions or attributes,
3. reasons about the relationships linking these attributes,
4. suggests observable features of these attributes,
5. considers the consequences of these choices for entity classification.
Module B. Causation and Explanation
This module explores causal reasoning and explanatory strategies in political science. Students will be introduced to various approaches to causal inference, from philosophical foundations to practical applications, across theory-driven and design-driven strategies.
Session 04. Frameworks
This session establishes the philosophical and methodological foundations of causal inference in political science. Students will be introduced to various conceptions of causation, ranging from Aristotelian principles to mechanisms and Directed Acyclic Graphs, as well as different epistemic strategies for establishing explanatory and causal claims, including inference to the best explanation and counterfactual designs.
Through this session, students will gain an understanding of various conceptions of causality and distinguish between different philosophical foundations of causal inference. They will learn criteria for evaluating explanatory strategies and begin to appreciate the epistemological trade-offs of various causal claims.
Core readings
Holland, P. W. (1986). Statistics and causal inference. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 81(396), 945-960. https://doi.org/10.1080/01621459.1986.10478354
Fearon, J. D. (1991). Counterfactuals and hypothesis testing in political science. World Politics, 43(2), 169-195. https://doi.org/10.2307/2010470
Mackie, J. L. (1965). Causes and conditions. American Philosophical Quarterly, 2(4), 245-264. https://www.jstor.org/stable/20009173
Further readings
Cunningham, S. (2021). Causal Inference: The Mixtape. Yale University Press, Ch.3. https://mixtape.scunning.com/03-directed_acyclical_graphs
Cinelli, C., Forney, A., & Pearl, J. (2024). A crash course in good and bad controls. Sociological Methods & Research, 53(3), 1071-1104. https://doi.org/10.1177/00491241221099552
Ducheyne, S. (2008): J.S. Mill's canons of induction: from true causes to provisional ones, History and Philosophy of Logic, 29:4, 361-376. http://doi.org/10.1080/01445340802164377
Glennan, S., Illari, P. & Weber, E. (2022). Six theses on mechanisms and mechanistic science. Journal for General Philosophy of Science 53, 143-161. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10838-021-09587-x
Lieberson, S. (1991). Small N's and big conclusions: an examination of the reasoning in comparative studies based on a small number of cases. Social Forces, 70(2), 307-320. https://doi.org/10.1093/sf/70.2.307
McGrew, T. (2003). Confirmation, heuristics, and explanatory reasoning. The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 54(4), 553-567. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3541678
Moravcsik, J. M. E. (1974). Aristotle on adequate explanations. Synthese, 28(1), 3-17. http://www.jstor.org/stable/20114949
Session 05. Theory-driven strategies
This session examines theory-driven approaches to causal analysis. Through question-guided group presentations and discussions, students will become familiar with the basic methodological choices involved in constructing and applying explanatory typologies, conducting Bayesian process tracing to test causal mechanisms, selecting conditions for Qualitative Comparative Analysis, and testing causal structures.
Through this session, students will refine their capacity to connect the philosophical foundations of causal inference with actual methodologies, appreciate their differences, contrast their strengths and limits, consider their appropriateness for specific 'why questions,' and clearly communicate complex concepts to broader audiences.
Discussion readings
Elman, C. (2005). Explanatory typologies in qualitative studies of international politics. International Organization, 59(2), 293-326. http://www.jstor.org/stable/3877906
Fairfield, Tasha, and Andrew E. Charman. 2017. Explicit Bayesian analysis for Process Tracing: guidelines, opportunities, and caveats. Political Analysis 25(3): 363-80. https://doi.org/10.1017/pan.2017.14
Amenta, E., Poulsen, J. D. (1994). Where to begin: a survey of five approaches to selecting independent variables for Qualitative Comparative Analysis. Sociological Methods & Research, 23(1), 22-53. https://doi.org/10.1177/0049124194023001002
Portfolio Deliverable II: Method Journal Entry
After the session, each student is asked to submit a max. 500-word journal entry -plus verified references - responding to the following:
"This session's discussion readings present distinct theory-driven strategies for causal analysis, each embedding theoretical reasoning into causal analysis in different ways. Please select one strategy and, in a maximum of 500 words, consider:
a) how does it use theory to reveal causation?
b) what assumptions about the relationship between theory and empirics does it require?
c) what kinds of research questions can it address?
Session 06. Design-based strategies
This session explores actual examples of design-based approaches to causal inference in political science. Through guided discussion of the assigned readings, student groups will consider how natural experiments leverage exogenous variation, conjoint survey experiments isolate causal effects, and paired comparisons can be used to test causal claims.
Through this session, students will refine their capacity to connect the philosophical foundations of designs for causal identification with actual methodologies, appreciate their differences, contrast their strengths and limits, and consider their appropriateness for specific 'why questions'.
Discussion readings
Tarrow, S. (2010). The strategy of paired comparison: Toward a theory of practice. Comparative Political Studies, 43(2), 230-259. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414009350044
Dunning, T. (2008). Improving causal inference: Strengths and limitations of natural experiments. Political Research Quarterly, 61(2), 282-293. https://doi.org/10.1177/1065912907306470
Bansak K, Hainmueller J, Hopkins DJ, Yamamoto T. (2021). Conjoint survey experiments. In: Druckman JN, Green DP, eds. Advances in Experimental Political Science. Cambridge University Press: 19- 41. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108777919.004
Portfolio Deliverable III: Method Journal Entry
After the session, each student is asked to submit a maximum 500-word journal entry - plus verified references - responding to the following:
"This session's discussion readings present distinct strategies for identifying causal effects, each resting on a different logic for making causal claims. Please select one strategy, concentrate on the logical foundations that make it suitable for causal identification, and consider:
a) what makes it capable of revealing causation rather than mere correlation?
b) on which assumptions does it build?
c) do you find it easy or hard to commit to these assumptions? Why?"
Session 07. Mixing and balancing theory and design
This session explores strategies that integrate theoretical and design-based approaches to achieve more robust causal inference. Through group discussion of the assigned readings, students will become familiar with how directed acyclic graphs and nested analysis can be used to establish causation.
Through this session, students will develop their capacity to integrate philosophical foundations of causal inference and actual methodologies, consider strengths and limits of nesting, consider its appropriateness to specific 'why questions,' and clearly communicate complex concepts to broader audiences.
Discussion readings
Kauffman, C. M. (2012). More than the sum of the parts: nested analysis in action. Qualitative & Multi-Method Research, 10(2). https://doi.org/10.5281/ZENODO.912350
Knox D, Lowe W, Mummolo J. (2020). Administrative records mask racially biased policing. American Political Science Review 114(3):619-637. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0003055420000039
Møller, J., & Skaaning, S. E. (2017). Explanatory typologies as a nested strategy of inquiry: Combining cross-case and within-case analyses. Sociological Methods & Research, 46(4), 1018-1048. https://doi.org/10.1177/0049124115613778
Portfolio Deliverable IV: Brief
After the session, students build on the phenomenon conceptualized in their Deliverable I and submit a maximum 750-word brief - plus verified references - that:
a) asks a causal/explanatory question about the phenomenon
b) selects a design-based strategy and a theory-based strategy, and connects them into a nested research design
c) considers whether this nesting can allow better responses to the driving question than single strategies alone, and why
Module C. Prediction
This module introduces the logic and applications of prediction in political science, distinguishing between predictive aims and explanatory goals. Students will learn how predictive strategies are employed to forecast political phenomena, test theoretical models, and guide decision-making. The module explores both traditional forecasting techniques and modern computational tools, with a focus on their epistemological underpinnings, methodological trade-offs, and relevance to political inquiry.
Session 08. Framework
This session establishes the conceptual foundations of predictive research in political science. Students will examine the distinction between explanatory and predictive goals, the theoretical and practical value of prediction, and the implications of different modeling strategies.
By the end of this session, students will be able to distinguish between explanatory and predictive approaches, understand the conceptual and methodological foundations of prediction, and grasp the different assumptions underlying predictive models in political science.
Core readings
Ray, J. L., and B. Russett. (1996). The future as arbiter of theoretical controversies: predictions, explanations, and the end of the Cold War. British Journal of Political Science 26, no. 4 441-70. http://www.jstor.org/stable/194092.
Shmueli, G. (2010). To explain or to predict? Statistical Science 25(3): 289-310; https://doi.org/10.1214/10-STS330
Further readings
Levi, M. (2004). An analytic narrative approach to puzzles and problems. In I. Shapiro, R. M. Smith, & T. E. Masoud (Eds.), Problems and Methods in the Study of Politics (pp. 201-226). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511492174.010
Granato, J., Lo, M., & Wong, M. C. S. (2021). Contemporary methodological practices. In Empirical Implications of Theoretical Models in Political Science (pp. 12-25). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781139026819.005
Grimmer, J., Roberts, M. E., & Stewart, B. M. (2021). Machine learning for social science: An agnostic approach. Annual Review of Political Science, 24(1), 395-419. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-polisci-053119-015921
de Slegte, J., Van Droogenbroeck, F., Spruyt, B., Verboven, S., & Ginis, V. (2024). The use of Machine Learning methods in political science: an in-depth literature review. Political Studies Review, 0(0). https://doi.org/10.1177/14789299241265084
Session 09. Strategies
Building on the conceptual distinctions from Session 08, this session explores practical strategies for conducting predictive research in political science. Through guided discussion of the assigned readings, students will analyze examples of different forecasting approaches. Emphasis will be placed on understanding the logic behind each strategy, the nature of the data it requires, and the assumptions it embeds about political processes.
Through this session, students will refine their capacity to identify key predictive strategies and assess their suitability for different types of political questions. They will understand the trade-offs between transparency, accuracy, and generalizability and begin to reason critically about the political and normative implications of predictive research.
Discussion readings
Nalepa, Monika. Captured commitments: an analytic narrative of transitions with transitional justice. World Politics 62, no. 2 (2010): 341-80. http://www.jstor.org/stable/40646203
Bechtel, M. M., & Leuffen, D. (2010). Forecasting European Union politics: Real-time forecasts in political time series analysis. European Union Politics, 11(2), 309-327. https://doi.org/10.1177/1465116509360846
Lewis-Beck, M. S., & Tien, C. (2012). Election forecasting for turbulent times. PS: Political Science & Politics, 45(4), 625-629. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1049096512000893
Muchlinski, D. et al. (2021) 'We need to go deeper: measuring electoral violence using convolutional neural networks and social media', Political Science Research and Methods, 9(1), 122-139. https://doi.org/10.1017/psrm.2020.32
Love, G. J., Carlin, R. E., & Singer, M. M. (2025). LASSOing the Governor's Mansion: A Machine-Learning Approach to Forecasting Gubernatorial Elections. PS: Political Science & Politics, 58(2), 226-233. doi:10.1017/S1049096524000866
Törnberg, P. (2023). ChatGPT-4 outperforms experts and crowd workers in annotating political Twitter messages with zero-shot learning. arXiv preprint arXiv:2304.06588. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2304.06588
Portfolio Deliverable V: Method Journal Entry
After the session, each student is asked to submit a maximum 500-word journal entry - plus verified references - responding to the following:
"This session's discussion readings present distinct approaches to prediction in political science. Please select one strategy, concentrate on the logical foundations that make it suitable for prediction, and consider:
a) What makes this approach capable of predicting political outcomes rather than merely describing patterns?
b) What assumptions does it make about the nature of political processes and their predictability?
c) Do you find it easy or hard to commit to these assumptions? Why?"
Module D. Wrapping up
Session 10. Research Proposal Workshop
This capstone session offers practical guidance for crafting a credible empirical research proposal. Students will learn how to integrate descriptive, explanatory, and/or predictive strategies into a coherent research design. The session will provide step-by-step advice on formulating research questions, justifying methodological choices, and presenting a persuasive case for empirical inquiry. Students will apply these principles in developing their final research proposal sketch.
Through this session, students will formulate a research question and outline a coherent empirical design integrating descriptive, explanatory, and/or predictive strategies. They will make informed methodological choices and justify them clearly, demonstrating readiness for self-directed empirical work and ongoing methodological development.
Deliverable VI: Research Proposal Memo
Building on previous briefs and journal entries, each student will upload a max 1000 word memo - plus verified references - that:
1. Develops her/his own empirical research question, paying special attention to conceptualization issues
2. Outlines a research strategy covered in the course
3. Justifies the consistency of the chosen research strategy with the research question
4. Possibly anticipates findings' limitations
PN: changes to the program may be made to better align with students' progress and engagement.

Modalità d'esame

Student learning is assessed throughout the entire course via a Portfolio composed of six assignments aligned with the core sessions. Each Portfolio task contributes to the development of skills in empirical research and directly targets specific learning objectives:
Deliverable I. Brief — 7 points
Students choose a political concept, define it based on the literature, deconstruct it into dimensions, and reflect on how measurement choices affect classification. This exercise builds conceptual clarity and precision in empirical description.
Dublin descriptors: 1, 2, 3, 4
Deliverable II. Method Journal Entry — 3 points
Students select one theory-driven causal strategy and critically reflect on its use of theory, assumptions about evidence, and vulnerability to falsification. This fosters epistemological awareness and analytical precision.
Dublin descriptors: 1, 2, 3, 4
Deliverable III. Method Journal Entry — 3 points
Focusing on one design-based causal strategy, students analyze its logic, assumptions, and inferential strength. This encourages critical judgment and methodological reasoning.
Dublin descriptors: 1, 2, 3, 4
Deliverable IV. Brief — 7 points
Students revisit their earlier concept and propose a causal question linked to it. They combine one theory-driven and one design-based strategy into a coherent nested design, justifying the pairing. This exercise integrates learning and advances design competence.
Dublin descriptors: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Deliverable V. Method Journal Entry — 3 points
Students select a predictive strategy and assess its logic, assumptions, and applicability to political processes. This fosters critical reflection on methodological trade-offs in predictive research.
Dublin descriptors: 1, 2, 3, 4
Deliverable VI. Research Proposal Memo — 10 points
In this capstone task, students formulate an original empirical research question, justify their conceptualization and chosen strategy, and sketch a coherent empirical design. The memo consolidates descriptive, explanatory, and predictive logics, demonstrating independent judgment, methodological integration, and readiness for delving into specific methods for thesis-level research.
Dublin descriptors: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Each deliverable is grounded in lectures, slide decks, readings, and class discussions. Participation in classroom discussions is not mandatory; however, it is strongly encouraged as it helps students complete their assignments far more effectively.
The portfolio-based assessment ensures that students are not evaluated on fragmented skills, but on their ability to synthesize concepts, critically familiarize themselves with methods, and develop original research proposals that reflect real-world research practice. Transparent rubrics will be circulated before discussion classes to enable students to assess their conceptual clarity and methodological awareness.
Lastly, students will refine their deliverables' grades during a final colloquium worth ±10% of the final grade. The colloquium builds on the Portfolio and allows each student to clarify, expand, or revise elements of their submitted work through an individual discussion. This summative assessment supports reflection on methodological decisions, encourages synthesis across assignments, and may result in an adjustment of the final grade by:
+10% if the discussion reveals outstanding reflective insight or significant methodological refinement;
0% if the oral confirms the coherence and quality of the portfolio;
−10% if significant gaps emerge in the student's understanding or ability to articulate core course principles.
The final Italian grade bands will correspond to the following qualitative evaluations:

  • lower than 17: Not passing: Major elements are missing or incoherent. Responses are undeveloped, and there is little to no evidence of engagement with course materials. Submission does not meet the expectations of MA-level work.
  • between 18 and 20: Perfunctory: Covers the task only at a surface level. Work appears rushed or incomplete, with significant weaknesses in explanation, structure, or use of literature, and minimal critical thinking.
  • between 21 and 23: Fair: Meets the basic requirements of the assignment. Key elements are addressed, but with confusion, lack of clarity, or limited engagement with the readings. Shows effort, but with notable gaps in argumentation or structure.
  • between 24 and 26: Good - A sound work that covers all required parts. Demonstrates an understanding of the main concepts, although the analysis may appear shallow. Some choices may be weakly justified or underdeveloped, but the overall structure holds.
  • between 27 and 29: Very Good - Demonstrates a solid understanding of the task and core ideas. Most components are well done, but depth, justification, or structure may be uneven in places. Shows strong potential but may lack the consistency or precision of excellent work.
  • 30: Excellent - Addresses all components with clarity and critical insight. Arguments are coherent and supported with appropriate literature. The structure is logical, and the reasoning is sound. It may have small areas that could be further refined.
  • 30 cum laude: Outstanding - Shows deep and original thinking throughout. Conceptual choices are sophisticated, well-justified, and demonstrate full command of the readings. All parts are handled with care and creativity.

Testi di riferimento

In addition to core, discussion, additional readings and slide decks, anyone wishing to improve their familiarity with political science theories and methods, or to approach the course topics from a different perspective, can refer to:
Lowndes, V., D. Marsh, and G. Stoker (eds.). (2018). Theory and Methods in Political Science (Fourth edition). Palgrave.
McNabb, D. E. (2020). Research Methods for Political Science: Quantitative, Qualitative and Mixed-Method Approaches. Routledge.
PN: course materials will be made available through the Ariel website. Please contact the instructor to get access.

Codice insegnamento empirical-research-political-sciences-0

Ethical theory and hard choices 1° anno · 6 CFU · PHIL-03/A · 0 file

The course aims to introduce the contemporary discussion in moral philosophy. The first section will: a) provide a characterization of morality, as a distinctive form of normativity, as compared to law, aesthetics, and…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course aims to introduce the contemporary discussion in moral philosophy. The first section will: a) provide a characterization of morality, as a distinctive form of normativity, as compared to law, aesthetics, and convention or etiquette; b) discuss the relationship and distinction of morality and religion and c) discuss the relationship of moral responsibility with the notion of free will. The second section will present the main normative theories of right action: a) the various forms of consequentialism (act- or rule-based), with their different attached theories of the good life (hedonism, desire-theory, objective-list theory); b) the different forms of deontological theories, both duty-based and rights-based; c) the main versions of either Aristotelian or agent-based virtue ethics. The third section will shortly present some theories on the nature of morality, such as expressivism, error theory, relativism, and some forms of moral realism.

At the end of the course, students are expected to possess the basic general information on both the normative and the metaethical discussions in moral philosophy; they are expected to acquire the language for the discussion of normative problems both in theoretical and applied ethics; they should have acquired the capacity to collect, present and discuss existing literature on a chosen topic in contemporary discussion, to prepare a short paper for the exam.

Programma

Section 1: The definition of morality
The idea of morality: moral norms vs. legal, aesthetic, and conventional norms
Moral judgment and the moral point of view
The relationship between religion and morality
Free will and moral responsibility
Section 2: The Status of Morality
Forms of moral subjectivism: metaethical and normative relativism, expressivism, error theory.
Forms of moral objectivism: naturalistic ethics, non-naturalistic moral realism.
Section 3: Normative theories
Forms of consequentialism: ethical egoism and utilitarianism
Act-consequentialism and rule-consequentialism
Theories of the good life: hedonism, desire theory, the 'objective list' theory
Deontological views in ethics: duty-based and rights-based theories
Theories of unconditional duties and theories of prima facie duties
Rights as side constraints: absolute and prima facie rights
The critique of 'modern morality' and Aristotelian views on virtue ethics
Agent-based vs. agent-focused virtue ethics

Modalità d'esame

The examination will consist in filling in a questionnaire with 30 multiple-choice questions concerning the course topics and the articles in the syllabus. There will also be an open question that the candidate will have to answer, selecting it in a list of 5 questions. Each multiple choice question scores one point, the open question scores three points: one point if correctly answers the questions; 2 points if it adds critical reflections; 3 points in case the answer is particularly rich and thoughtful. Good scoring in the open question is vital to reach the highest mark.

Testi di riferimento

  • W. Frankena, Ethics, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs NJ 1973, chap. 1
  • P.F. Strawson, Freedom and resentment, Proceedings of the British Academy, 48, 1962, pp. 187-211
  • H.L.A. Hart, The Concept of Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford 1997, pp. 155-184
  • J. Berg, How could ethics depend on religion?, in Singer (ed.), A Companion to Ethics, Blackwell, Oxford, 1991, pp. 525-533
  • B. Eggleston, Act utilitarianism, in B. Eggleston, D. Miller (eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Utilitarianism, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2014, pp. 125-145
  • B. Hooker, Rule-Consequentialism, in R. Shafer-Landau (ed.), Ethical Theory. An Anthology, Wiley Blackwell, Oxford 2012, pp. 428-440
  • T. Nagel, The View from Nowhere, Oxford University Press, New York 1986, chap. IX, pp. 164-185; repr. in S. Darwall (ed.), Deontology, Blackwell, Oxford 2003, pp. 90-111.
  • D. Ross, What makes right acts right?, in R. Shafer-Landau (ed.), Ethical Theory. An Anthology, Wiley Blackwell, Oxford 2012, pp. 756-762
  • R. Hursthouse, Normative virtue ethics, in R. Shafer-Landau (ed.), Ethical Theory. An Anthology, Wiley Blackwell, Oxford 2012, pp. 645-652
  • M. Slote, Agent-Based Virtue Ethics, in R. Shafer-Landau (ed.), Ethical Theory. An Anthology, Wiley Blackwell, Oxford 2012, pp. 653-663
  • R. Shafer-Landau, Ethics as Philosophy : A Defense of Ethical Nonnaturalism, in Metaethics Afte Moore, ed. Horgan & Timmons, Oxofrd University Press 2006, pp. 209-232
  • J. Mackie, The Subjectivity of Values, in R. Shafer-Landau (ed.), Ethical Theory. An Anthology, Wiley Blackwell, Oxford 2012, pp. 22-30
  • D. Wong, Relativism, in Singer (ed.), A Companion to Ethics, Blackwell, Oxford, 1991, pp. 442-450

Codice insegnamento ethical-theory-and-hard-choices-0

Gender theory and social issues 1° anno · 2° semestre · 6 CFU · GSPS-05/A · 0 file

The course aims to provide students with critical theoretical and methodological competencies to analyse social issues using a gender-sensitive and intersectional approach.It pursues two primary objectives:(1) to equip…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course aims to provide students with critical theoretical and methodological competencies to analyse social issues using a gender-sensitive and intersectional approach.It pursues two primary objectives:(1) to equip students with the conceptual tools needed to understand and critically analyse gendered social phenomena in both historical and contemporary contexts;(2) to introduce students to feminist and intersectional research methods, and support them in designing and conducting a small-scale empirical study.Throughout the course, students will learn to define research objectives, formulate relevant questions, and develop appropriate methodological tools for qualitative, gender-sensitive sociological research. They will also engage in textual analysis, group discussions, classroom presentations, and academic writing.

At the end of the course, students will be able to:- Demonstrate a thorough understanding of foundational and contemporary gender theories.- Identify and apply gender and intersectional approaches to theoretical and empirical problems.- Design a qualitative research project, from research questions to methodological planning.- Collect and analyse qualitative data (e.g. interviews, policy documents).- Engage in scholarly discussions and critically assess academic literature.- Communicate and critically reflect on research findings, both orally and in writing, addressing specialist and non-specialist audiences.- Cultivate independent learning skills for continuing engagement with gender-related research and debates.

Programma

This course provides students with critical theoretical and methodological tools to analyse social issues through the lens of gender and intersectionality. Emphasis is placed on engaging with both classical and contemporary feminist and gender theories, and on developing qualitative research skills capable to adopt gender and intersectional approaches. In particular, the course pursues two primary objectives:

  • To equip students with conceptual frameworks to understand and critically analyse gendered social phenomena in their historical and contemporary configurations.
  • To introduce students to gender and intersectional qualitative research methods and support them in designing and conducting a small-scale empirical study.
    The course is organised into four main parts:
  • Part I - Gender theories and social issues: This section introduces foundational and contemporary feminist and gender theories, with particular attention to the concept of gender as a practice. Moving beyond essentialist or static understandings, the course draws on sociological and feminist contributions that conceptualise gender as something that is collaboratively enacted, performed, and situated, rather than something that individuals are or have. In particular, students will become familiar with the epistemological shifts that have shaped gender theory within the social sciences, and they will be introduced to key debates on the construction of gendered identities, institutions, and power relations. This part of the course lays the theoretical groundwork for the analysis of social issues explored in the later parts of the course.
  • Part II - Intersectional methodologies: This section introduces students to qualitative research methodologies with a focus on how gender and other intersecting dimensions, such as class, sexuality, disability, age, and migration status, shape both research subjects and research processes. The aim is to equip students with the tools to design and conduct empirical studies that foreground gender as a situated and relational practice. Particular attention will be paid to: the epistemological foundations of feminist and intersectional methodologies; the construction of research questions sensitive to gendered power dynamics; case selection and sampling strategies; ethical considerations and reflexivity in fieldwork; the development of interview guides; data analysis. Students will participate in hands-on workshops focused on the practical aspects of designing a small-scale research project.
  • Part III - Invited speakers: In this part of the course recent studies will be presented by invited speakers and discussed in the classroom, in order to illustrate how gender and intersectionality can be operationalised in research practice. These studies serve as substantive case examples to demonstrate the theoretical and methodological approaches introduced in Parts I and II. Discussion of selected studies in the following areas: (i) politics of caring in digital capitalism; (ii) feminist perspectives on motherhoods; (iii) critical approaches to masculinities; (iv) feminist social movements; (v) gendered and intersectional experiences of space. The reading list for this part will be assigned at the beginning of the course.
  • Part IV - Student research presentations: In the final part of the course, students will present the outcomes of their collaborative research projects. These presentations are an integral part of the learning process, allowing students to reflect on their methodological choices and the theoretical lenses adopted in their research exercises.

Modalità d'esame

Assessment Methods and Criteria
For ATTENDING students, assessment is based on a combination of
1. class participation and posts (20%)
2. in-class presentation of the research work carried out (30%)
3. writing of the final paper (50%)
1.
Attendance will be monitored via the EasyAcademy suite. Students who attend at least 75% of the lectures are considered to be attending; a maximum of 5 absences is therefore permitted.
Students are expected to participate regularly and contribute to class discussions. Please pay attention to group dynamics so that everyone feels comfortable to speak up.
Posts must be submitted prior to lectures featuring invited speakers. The purpose of these posts is to prepare informed, critical questions for the speaker based on the assigned readings. Posts that merely summarize the text will not receive credit.
Each post (maximum 200 words) must contain:

  • One or two questions for the speaker that engage directly with the reading. Strong questions should probe the author's argument, methodology, or findings rather than requesting general clarifications.
  • A brief rationale (1-2 sentences) explaining where in the text the question originates and why it matters.
    Students must begin directly with their questions; introductions or background context should be omitted. The writing must adhere to a formal academic style without the use of bullet points or numbered lists. Posts submitted after the deadline will not be considered.
    2.
    The last classes will be devoted to the presentation of the research exercises carried out by the attending students. In particular, through class discussion on how to construct a qualitative research design and interview guide, the course aims to train students to conduct qualitative social research aimed at investigating social issue with a gender and intersectional approach, and to be able to present the empirical material collected in class.
    3.
    The written paper - to be developed in pairs (8,000 words, excluding appendix) - aims to test the students' knowledge and analytical skills in line with the expected learning outcomes. In particular, the paper is to be developed on the basis of a research exercise to be conducted using the qualitative interview technique. The paper is assessed on the basis of the ability to critically discuss the issues addressed during the course. In particular, the paper must consist of five parts:
    i. Illustration of the topic to be addressed and the research question to be answered
    ii. Description of the research design and the empirical context in which it was conducted
    iii. Argumentation of the research method used (offline or online interviews)
    iv. Presentation of the main research findings
    v. Discussion and conclusions
    Finally, the interview guide used, and the informed consent must be included in the appendix.
    For the final paper, students must reference the assigned readings and are encouraged to use additional scholarly sources. The assessment takes into account the ability to critically illustrate their arguments and the appropriateness of the specific language relating to the investigation of gender and society. The ability to make connections between the concepts addressed during the course and the research exercise carried out constitute further elements of assessment.
    --
    For NON-ATTENDING students, the assessment is based on a combination of:
    1. writing of the final paper (50%)
    2. oral examination (50%)
    1.
    The written paper - to be developed individually (5,000 words excluding appendix) - aims to test students' knowledge and analytical skills in line with the expected learning outcomes. In particular, the paper is to be developed on the basis of a research exercise to be conducted using the qualitative interview technique. The paper is assessed on the basis of the ability to critically discuss the issues addressed during the course. In particular, the paper must consist of five parts:
    i. Illustration of the topic to be addressed and the research question to be answered
    ii. Description of the research design and the empirical context in which it was conducted
    iii. Argumentation of the research method used (offline or online interviews)
    iv. Presentation of the main research findings
    v. Discussion and conclusions
    Finally, the interview guide used, and the informed consent should be included in the appendix.
    For the final paper, students must reference the assigned readings and are encouraged to use additional scholarly sources. The assessment takes into account the ability to critically illustrate their arguments and the appropriateness of the specific language relating to the investigation of gender and society.
    2.
    The oral examination will take place approximately two weeks after the submission of the paper and will cover both the topics addressed in the paper and the texts indicated in the bibliography of the course. No materials are allowed during the oral exam.

Testi di riferimento

THEORETICAL FOUNDATIONS:

  • Stacey, J., & Thorne, B. (1985). The missing feminist revolution in sociology. Social problems, 32(4), 301-316.
  • Scott, J. (1986). Gender: A Useful Category of Historical Analysis. American Historical Review 91:1053-75.
  • West, C., & Zimmerman, D. H. (1987). Doing gender. Gender & society, 1(2), 125-151.
  • Acker, J. (1992). From sex roles to gender institutions. Contemporary Sociology. 21(5), pp.565-569.
    A THEORY OF GENDER PRACTICES
  • Poggio, Barbara (2006). Outline of a theory of gender practices. Gender Work and Organization, 13(3), 225.
    Doing gender:
  • Gherardi, S. (1994). The gender we think, the gender we do in our everyday organizational lives. Human relations, 47(6), 591-610.
  • An article of your choice between:
    Goffman, Erving (1976) Gender Display. Studies in the Anthropology of Visual Communication, 3, 301-31.
    Garfinkel, Harold (1967) Studies in Ethnomethodology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, pp. 116-185.
    Performing gender:
    A book of your choice between:
  • Butler, Judith (1990). Gender Troubles: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity. Routledge.
  • Kondo, D. K. (1990). Crafting selves: Power, gender, and discourses of identity in a Japanese workplace. University of Chicago Press.
    Positioning gender:
  • Alcoff, Linda (1988). Cultural feminism versus post-structuralism: The identity crisis in feminist theory. Signs: Journal of women in culture and society, 13(3), 405-436.
  • Davies, Bronwyn and Harrè, Rom (1989) Positioning: The Discursive Production of Selves. Journal of the Theory of Social Behaviour, 20(1), 43-63.
    Practicing gender:
  • Connell, Robert (1995). Masculinities. University of California Press.
  • Martin, Patricia Y. (2001). Mobilizing masculinities': women's experiences of men at work. Organization, 8(4), 587-618.
  • Martin, Patricia Y. (2003). "Said and done" versus "saying and doing" gendering practices, practicing gender at work. Gender & Society, 17(3), 342-366.
    Post-gender:
  • Barad, Karen (2003) Posthumanist Performativity: Toward an Understanding of How Matter Comes to Matter. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 28,3: 801-831.
  • Cozza, Michela, & Gherardi, Silvia (2023). Posthuman feminism and feminist new materialism: towards an ethico-onto-epistemology in research practices. In Handbook of feminist research methodologies in management and organization studies (pp. 55-71). Edward Elgar.
    EPISTEMOLOGICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL FOUNDATIONS:
  • Harding, Sandra (1987) Is There a Feminist Method?. In C. Seale (ed.) Social research methods: A reader. Routledge, pp. 456-464.
  • Rodriguez, J. K., & Guenther, E. A. (2025). Recognizing and Working with Intersectionality in Field Research. In D. Hammett & N. Holmes, The Routledge Handbook of Field Research (1st edn, pp. 66-77). Routledge.
  • Holstein, J. A., & Gubrium, J. F. (2016). Narrative Practice and the Active Interview. In D. Silverman (ed.) Qualitative Research, Part II - Interviews and Focus Groups, Sage, pp. 67-82.
    In addition to the core reading list, two articles per guest speaker will be assigned to accompany the invited talks. These readings will be selected in consultation with the invited speakers and communicated to students at the beginning of the course.

Codice insegnamento gender-theory-and-social-issues-2

Labour market and inequalities 1° anno · 6 CFU · GSPS-08/A · 0 file

The objective of this course is to equip students with an understanding of the challenges encountered in contemporary labour markets within developed societies. Additionally, the course seeks to delve into and debate the…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The objective of this course is to equip students with an understanding of the challenges encountered in contemporary labour markets within developed societies. Additionally, the course seeks to delve into and debate the primary sources of inequalities experienced by individuals in the labour market, influenced by factors such as social background, gender, and migratory status. While focusing primarily on describing the characteristics of the Italian labour market and the associated inequalities, the course frequently draws comparisons with other countries.

Students will acquire key tools to examine the dynamics of labour markets and the challenges related to inequality. They will also develop the ability to interpret and engage in critical discussions of findings concerning labour market dynamics and inequalities, as presented in both public discourse and academic literature.Specifically, by the end of the course, students will be able to:1. Knowledge and understanding- Describe the main concepts used in the sociological analysis of labour markets and social inequalities in developed countries.- Identify and explain key indicators used to measure labour market structures, transformations over time, and patterns of inequality.- Discuss major theoretical approaches and empirical findings related to inequalities based on gender, migratory status, and social background.2. Applying knowledge and understanding- Apply theoretical frameworks to interpret data and empirical research on labour markets and inequalities.- Analyze the transformation of the Italian labour market and compare it with developments in other national contexts.3. Making judgements- Critically evaluate empirical findings on labour markets and inequality presented in the academic literature.- Assess claims and narratives related to labour and inequality in political and media discourse.- Formulate well-reasoned arguments on key issues and developments concerning labour market dynamics and social inequality.4. Communication skills- Summarize and present empirical research findings on labour markets and inequalities in a clear, structured, and coherent manner.- Engage effectively in classroom discussions, expressing ideas clearly and contributing constructively to collective debate.- Deliver individual or group presentations, demonstrating the ability to communicate key argu-ments and reasoning clearly and persuasively.

Programma

The course is structured into two main parts. In the first part, students will be introduced to the fundamental concepts underpinning the sociological analysis of labour markets and inequalities. This part will explore key concepts and indicators used to examine the structure and changes of labour markets, as well as inequalities within them. In the second part, the focus will shift to exploring the primary sources and dimensions of inequalities within labour markets. Through examination of recent empirical research, the course will analyze and discuss key evidence pertaining to inequalities based on social background, gender, and migratory status.

Modalità d'esame

For attending students:
Student assessment will be based on two components: an oral presentation and a written exam.
The oral presentation will consist of a critical review of the state of the art on a selected topic covered in the course (or more broadly, on issues related to labour markets or inequalities).
The written exam will include both multiple-choice and open-ended questions, designed to assess students' understanding of key topics covered in class.
For non-attending students:
Assessment will be based entirely on a written exam, which will include both multiple-choice and open-ended questions covering the full set of mandatory readings.

Testi di riferimento

In the first part of the course, a selection of mandatory readings - comprising book chapters and scientific articles - will be assigned. The complete list of readings will be made available before the course begins.
In the second part of the course, selected chapters from the following book will be assigned:
Platt, L. (2019). Understanding Inequalities: Stratification and Difference. John Wiley & Sons.
These chapters will be supplemented by additional readings drawn from empirical research articles, which will help illustrate how key theoretical concepts are applied in contemporary sociological research.

Codice insegnamento labour-market-and-inequalities

Liberal rights and social justice 1° anno · 1° semestre · 6 CFU · GIUR-17/A · 0 file

This course aims to provide students with a critical understanding of liberalism as a political theory, considering both its conception of constitutional rights and its approach to political justice. Students will engage…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

This course aims to provide students with a critical understanding of liberalism as a political theory, considering both its conception of constitutional rights and its approach to political justice. Students will engage with key philosophical debates on the limits and potential of liberalism when it comes to addressing social justice issues, particularly those concerning liberty, differences, and inequalities. Another objective is to enable students to critically assess liberal theories of justice, examining their internal tensions, the critiques they face, and the extent to which they can respond to different forms of social injustice. The course also seeks to enhance students' ability to apply normative political theories to contemporary debates, as well as their critical reasoning and informed discussion skills.

By the end of the course, students are expected to:Knowledge and understanding- Demonstrate a clear understanding of liberalism as a theory of constitutional rights and political justice, as well as its limitations in achieving social justice.- Demonstrate an understanding of key liberal principles such as the priority of basic liberties, liberty-limiting principles, liberal neutrality, and principles of distributive justice.Applying knowledge and understanding- Critically apply liberal theory to assess real-world issues related to basic liberties, economic inequality, sexism and racism, and identity politics.- Analyse institutional mechanisms, such as judicial review, the rule of law, and judicial guarantees, from a normative perspective.Making judgements- Evaluate the strengths and limitations of liberalism when it comes to responding to contemporary demands for social justice.- Formulate well-argued positions on contested issues such as meritocracy, equal opportunity and structural injustice.Communication skills- Present complex theoretical arguments in a clear, structured and persuasive manner.- Engage constructively in academic debate, demonstrating an openness to alternative viewpoints.Learning skills- Demonstrate the ability to read, understand and summarise academic texts on political philosophy and legal theory.- Reflect critically on the relationship between normative theory and political practice, developing habits of independent and lifelong learning.- Demonstrate the ability to independently locate relevant philosophical literature using search engines and bibliographic repositories.

Programma

The course examines liberal theories of social justice and the main philosophical debates surrounding them. Its primary object is the institutional structure of a political society and, where relevant, the social norms and practices that shape the conduct, opportunities, status, and life prospects of its members. The course asks how different liberal theories address the exercise of political power, the protection of individual freedom and rights, the organisation of social and economic institutions, and persistent forms of inequality and disadvantage.
The course begins from the idea that questions of social justice arise not only from individual conduct but also from the way institutions define rights, distribute powers and resources, structure opportunities, and coordinate social cooperation. It therefore considers both formal political and legal institutions and, in selected areas, informal social norms and structural patterns of inequality. Particular attention is paid to the division of responsibility between individuals and institutions in creating, sustaining, or correcting unjust social arrangements.
Rather than being organised around a single author or a comprehensive theory, the course follows a problem-oriented structure. John Rawls's theory of justice remains a central reference point, but it is examined alongside competing liberal approaches, libertarian and egalitarian alternatives, feminist and multicultural critiques, theories of recognition, and debates on global justice. The aim is to compare rival principles and arguments and to show how general normative ideas bear on concrete institutional and policy choices.
The course first introduces the concept of social justice and competing conceptions of individual freedom, before examining the conditions under which individual freedom may legitimately be restricted and the reasons for assigning priority to certain fundamental rights. It then turns to property rights and taxation, considering both their moral justification and their institutional character. Questions of fundamental equality and equal consideration provide the basis for examining political equality and democracy, while equality of opportunity is explored both as a general principle and through the specific case of health policy.
A further group of topics concerns the distribution of economic and social advantages and the organisation of work. The course compares major principles of distributive justice and examines the moral significance of economic inequality, before considering the relation between income and work, social minima, conditional and unconditional income support, and the possibility of a post-work society. It also examines structural forms of injustice connected with the division of care work and with relations of authority, rights, and control within productive organisations.
The course then addresses the challenges that pluralism and social difference pose to liberal theories of justice. It considers disagreement about religion, morality, culture, and ways of life, as well as liberal responses based on toleration, neutrality, autonomy, and pluralism. These issues are further explored through debates on multiculturalism and minority rights, recognition and identity politics, and the relations among gender, gender identity, social classification, personal freedom, and emancipation from restrictive social roles.
Finally, the course extends questions of justice beyond the domestic political community. It examines the scope of principles of justice, human rights, global inequality, and duties across borders, before considering migration policy and the rights of migrants, including questions of admission and exclusion, asylum, integration, residence, and access to political membership.
Across these topics, the course places particular emphasis on the relation between abstract principles and institutional design, on conflicts among liberal values, and on the capacity and limits of liberal theories to identify and address both distributive and structural forms of injustice.
Lectures
1. Liberal Theories of Social Justice
2. Conceptions of Individual Freedom
3. The Limits of Individual Freedom
4. Fundamental Rights and Their Priority
5. Property and Justice
6. Justice and Taxation
7. Fundamental Equality and Equal Consideration
8. Justice and Democracy
9. Equality of Opportunity
10. Justice and Health Policy
11. Distributive Justice
12. Justice, Income, and Work
13. Justice and the Division of Care Work
14. Workers' Rights and Workplace Justice
15. Liberalism and Disagreement about the Good
16. Multiculturalism and Minority Rights
17. Recognition and Identity Politics
18. Gender, Gender Identity, and Freedom
19. Global Justice and Human Rights
20. Migration Policy and Migrants' Rights

Modalità d'esame

Different assessment methods and criteria apply to attending and non-attending students. To obtain attending status, students must register for the course and attend at least three fifths of the lectures (12 out of 20).
All students may choose between the Traditional Reading Path and the Exploratory AI-Assisted Path described in the Course Bibliography and Study Guide. The written examination has the same structure under both paths, but the bibliographic material on which questions are based differs.
For attending students, the final grade is based on attendance (20%) and a 90-minute written exam (80%). The written exam consists of 30 multiple-choice questions (40% of the written-exam grade) and three open-ended questions, of which students must answer two (60%). Students must obtain a passing grade in both sections. The exam covers the topics discussed in class and either the required texts assigned to the Traditional Reading Path or the full fifty-item bibliography assigned to the Exploratory AI-Assisted Path. Students following the Traditional Reading Path who pass the written exam must take a compulsory oral examination; for students following the Exploratory AI-Assisted Path, the oral examination is optional. In either case, it may raise or lower the provisional final grade by up to three points. The oral examination is required for students seeking 30 cum laude.
For non-attending students, the written exam has the same structure and requirements. It covers the bibliographic material associated with the chosen study path and the additional materials specified in the syllabus for non-attending students. Students who pass the written exam must take a compulsory oral examination, irrespective of the chosen path; the oral examination may raise or lower the written-exam grade by up to three points.
Further details concerning attendance requirements, scoring, examination procedures, and evaluation criteria will be published on the MyAriel course site before the start of the lessons.

Testi di riferimento

General information
Students may choose between two alternative strategies for preparing the course bibliography. The Traditional Reading Path requires close and sustained reading of a smaller selection of required texts. The Exploratory AI-Assisted Path requires students to acquire a basic familiarity with all fifty works in the full course bibliography, primarily through the critical and interactive use of generative AI. The two paths are equally valid but are designed to develop different forms of familiarity with the philosophical literature.
The Traditional Reading Path prioritises depth, first-hand textual knowledge, and reconstruction of philosophical arguments; the Exploratory AI-Assisted Path prioritises breadth and orientation across the field. Detailed instructions on the two approaches, their expected workload, the use of original texts and generative AI, and the topics on which students should concentrate are provided in a separate Course Bibliography and Study Guide available on the MyAriel course site.
Full course bibliography (Exploratory AI-Assisted Path)
1. Berlin, I. "Two Concepts of Liberty" (1958).
2. Cohen, G.A. "The Structure of Proletarian Unfreedom" (1983).
3. Taylor, C. "What's Wrong with Negative Liberty" (1979).
4. Pettit, P. "Freedom as Antipower" (1996).
5. Dworkin, R. "Liberalism" (1978).
6. Dworkin, R. "Taking Rights Seriously" (1970).
7. Scanlon, T.M. "Rights, Goals, and Fairness" (1978).
8. Mill, J.S. On Liberty (1859).
9. Feinberg, J. Offense to Others (1985).
10. Raz, J. The Morality of Freedom (1986).
11. Arneson, R.J. "Paternalism, Utility, and Fairness" (1989).
12. Sunstein, C.R. Why Nudge? (2014).
13. Hayek, F.A. The Mirage of Social Justice (1976).
14. Nozick, R. Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974).
15. Nagel, T. "Libertarianism Without Foundations" (1975).
16. Waldron, J. The Right to Private Property (1988).
17. Murphy, L. & Nagel, T. "Taxes, Redistribution, and Public Provision" (2001).
18. Van Parijs, P. Real Freedom for All (1995).
19. Rawls, J. A Theory of Justice (1971).
20. Taylor, C. "The Nature and Scope of Distributive Justice" (1985).
21. Rawls, J. Political Liberalism (1993).
22. Galston, W.A. "Two Concepts of Liberalism" (1995).
23. Barry, B. Justice as Impartiality (1995).
24. Cohen, G.A. "Where the Action Is: On the Site of Distributive Justice" (1997).
25. Nagel, T. Equality and Partiality (1991).
26. Daniels, N. Just Health (2008).
27. White, S. The Civic Minimum (2003).
28. Thomas, A. Republic of Equals (2017).
29. Christiano, T. The Constitution of Equality (2008).
30. Dworkin, R. Sovereign Virtue (2000).
31. Arneson, R.J. "Equality and Equal Opportunity for Welfare" (1989).
32. Sen, A. Inequality Reexamined (1992).
33. Anderson, E. "What Is the Point of Equality?" (1999).
34. Scanlon, T.M. Why Does Inequality Matter? (2018).
35. Miller, D. On Nationality (1995).
36. Rawls, J. The Law of Peoples (1999).
37. Pogge, T.W. World Poverty and Human Rights (2002).
38. Risse, M. On Global Justice (2012).
39. Nussbaum, M.C. Frontiers of Justice (2006).
40. Okin, S.M. Justice, Gender, and the Family (1989).
41. Schouten, G. Liberalism, Neutrality, and the Gendered Division of Labor (2019).
42. Kymlicka, W. Multicultural Citizenship (1995).
43. Okin, S.M. "Feminism and Multiculturalism: Some Tensions" (1998).
44. Anderson, E. The Imperative of Integration (2010).
45. Young, I.M. Justice and the Politics of Difference (1990).
46. Fraser, N. & Honneth, A. Redistribution or Recognition? (2003).
47. Brown, W. "Wounded Attachments" (1993).
48. Young, M. The Rise of the Meritocracy, 1870-2033 (1958).
49. Sandel, M.J. The Tyranny of Merit (2020).
50. Anderson, E. Private Government (2017).
Required texts (Traditional Reading Path)
Students choosing the Traditional Reading Path are required to study the texts listed below. All required readings are available through the University Library's digital resources. For Mill's On Liberty, students may use any complete edition.
1. Mill, J.S. On Liberty (1859). Any complete edition.
2. Rawls, J. Justice as Fairness: A Restatement. Edited by Erin Kelly. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2001.
3. Rawls, J. "The Law of Peoples." Critical Inquiry 20, no. 1 (1993): 36-68.
4. Young, I.M. Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1990. Chapters 1, 2, 6, and 7.
For non-attending students
Non-attending students may choose either the Traditional Reading Path or the Exploratory AI-Assisted Path described above. Their bibliography preparation therefore follows the same requirements as for attending students: close study of the required texts for the Traditional Reading Path, or guided exploration of all fifty works for the Exploratory AI-Assisted Path. In addition, they are required to study the following fifteen entries from the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (SEP), which provide the general conceptual framework that attending students acquire through lectures and follow-up study:
1. Liberalism
2. Positive and Negative Liberty
3. The Limits of Law
4. Paternalism
5. Libertarianism
6. John Rawls
7. Distributive Justice
8. Equality
9. Equality of Opportunity
10. Social Minimum
11. Democracy
12. Global Justice
13. Feminist Political Philosophy
14. Multiculturalism
15. Recognition
Non-attending students are not expected to study every section of each SEP entry with the same degree of attention. They should concentrate particularly on the concepts, arguments, authors, and debates relevant to the course and to the material associated with their chosen study path. Further guidance on the sections to prioritise will be provided on the MyAriel course site.

Codice insegnamento liberal-rights-and-social-justice-2

Migrations and cultural diversity 1° anno · 6 CFU · GSPS-08/B · 0 file

The course aims to provide students with critical lenses to understand the process of migration in relation to systems implemented to govern human mobility at the global level. It aims to provide the knowledge and…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course aims to provide students with critical lenses to understand the process of migration in relation to systems implemented to govern human mobility at the global level. It aims to provide the knowledge and ability to understand complex social phenomena like international migration and the production of borders. The course focuses on four main topics: the government of human mobility at the global level (how containment policies implemented to govern migration produce inequalities); borders (how the bordering process works on the ground, which are the actors involved in the negotiation of borders, and how borders affects migrants' everyday lives); asylum (as example to analyze the power relationship between the state, the forms of government of the population, and the subjects governed); solidarity (as space and practice of autonomy and resistance). The course aims to offer a deep knowledge on these four topics through the understanding of key issues and through the analyses of case-studies in empirical research.

At the end of the course, students should be able to deeply understand key issues of contemporary migration processes, to critically discuss the bordering process in relation to human mobility and systems to govern it, and to engage with related topics like racism, forms of resistance and solidarity in the field of asylum and migration. The analyses of specific case-studies combined with individual/group presentations, in-class discussions and exercises, should provide students with the ability to apply their acquired knowledge. Ultimately, students should be able to recognize and discover the new and relevant challenges posed by the process of migration.

Programma

At the end of the course, students should be able to deeply understand key issues of contemporary migration processes, to critically discuss the bordering process in relation to human mobility and systems to govern it, and to engage with related topics like racism, forms of resistance and solidarity in the field of asylum and migration. The analyses of specific case-studies combined with individual/group presentations, in-class discussions and exercises, should provide students with the ability to apply their acquired knowledge. Ultimately, students should be able to recognize and discover the new and relevant challenges posed by the process of migration.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento migrations-and-cultural-diversity-0

Political order, violence and institutions 1° anno · 1° semestre · 9 CFU · GSPS-02/A · 0 file

Primary goal of this course is introducing students to core elements studying politics, with a specific focus on the state and its ruptures. Through an analytical and empirical approach, we intend to foster analytical…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

Primary goal of this course is introducing students to core elements studying politics, with a specific focus on the state and its ruptures. Through an analytical and empirical approach, we intend to foster analytical thinking skills and facilitate independent thinking to understand broad and deep political phenomena. By the end of the course, students should be able to:- Articulate the foundational principles of politics.- Apply key political science concepts and theories to explain various aspects of political orders, conflict and cooperation.- Utilize analytical tools to identify patterns and dynamics across and within states and over time.- Evaluate trends in conflict, institutional, and political dynamics.- Develop effective research and communication skills to engage in scholarly literature and contribute in a critical way in political debates.

Upon successful completion of this course, students will demonstrate proficiency in:- Understanding and critically analyzing political science heories and concepts, applying them to real-world scenarios.- Identifying and interpreting political patterns and dynamics using analytical frameworks and methodologies.- Evaluating empirical trends in institutions, policies, and political dynamics.- Communicating findings and insights from the scientific literature through discussions and written assignments.- Contributing constructively to class discussions.- Applying theoretical and analytical insights to address contemporary political challenges.

Programma

The course program seeks to balance conceptual and theoretical debates with historical political processes and contemporary real-world issues and trends.
The first part of the course will address foundational macro-level questions, such as: What is politics? What are institutions? What is political violence? What is political order? And what is the state?
The second part will take a more empirical approach to examine specific political issues and processes, linked to the creation of order, core political institutions, and processes of political violence.
We will begin by focusing on topics central to the creation of political order and systems of governance. These include: State formation and state capacity; Colonialism and its legacies; Political regimes (e.g., democracies, autocracies); Democratization and democratic backsliding; Forms of (democratic) governance (e.g., presidential and parliamentary systems).
We will then turn to the various challenges to the state (state rupture), governance, and regime stability. These include both (largely) non-violent phenomena—such as political corruption, clientelism, and civil resistance—and violent forms of contention, including civil war, genocide, coups, and organized crime.
A detailed week-by-week schedule, including session topics and the mandatory readings for each class, will be made available on MyAriel before the start of the course and presented in full during the first session.

Modalità d'esame

Final Exam (2-hour written exam)
The exam will be closed-book and will consist of multiple-choice and short, open-ended questions based on the mandatory readings and class materials (slides will be made available via MyAriel).

Testi di riferimento

There will be no single assigned textbook. Instead, we will read scholarly articles and book chapters by a variety of scholars who are leading experts on the topics covered in each session. Students are expected to complete the assigned reading before each session. To keep the workload manageable, readings will be limited to one paper or chapter per session.

Codice insegnamento political-order-violence-and-institutions

Rationality, rules and institutions 1° anno · 2° semestre · 9 CFU · ECON-01/A · 0 file

The course aims at- introducing students to the fundamental principles of rational choice theory for the analysis of institutions;- providing knowledge of the main issues discussed in contemporary philosophy of the…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course aims at- introducing students to the fundamental principles of rational choice theory for the analysis of institutions;- providing knowledge of the main issues discussed in contemporary philosophy of the social sciences, with particular emphasis on social ontology

At the end of the course the students will have acquired- some basic skills in the formation and use of scientific concepts and theories;- the capacity to understand the theories that philosophers, psychologists, biologists and economists have put forward to explain the emergence of institutions;- knowledge of the cognitive skills that allow human beings to engage in coordination and cooperation, on a scale of complexity that is unknown in the natural world;- the ability to analyse and critically assess the main arguments brought in favour and against different views concerning the nature and functions of institutions, and the emergence of cooperation;- the capacity to identify the ways in which these debates may be resolved, and how their solutions may contribute to scientific progress and understanding;- the capacity to present the main arguments independently, satisfying the main requirements of scholarly writing.

Programma

This unit is devoted to foundational debates in social ontology, focusing on the nature of institutions. Students will understand the theories that philosophers, psychologists and economists have put forward to analyse institutions and explain their emergence. They will also learn about the cognitive capacities which allow human beings to engage in coordination and cooperation. Students will understand and critically assess the main arguments in favour and against the views presented in the literature, with the aim of identifying the ways in which debates in the foundations of social science may be resolved.
PART 1 (weeks 1-7)
1. Individualism and rational choice

  • Weber, M. (1921) "The Interpretive Understanding of Social Action", in Readings in the Philosophy of the Social Sciences, edited by M. Brodbeck. Macmillan, pp. 19-33. [in ariel]
  • Angner, E. (2012) A Course in Behavioral Economics, Ch. 2 ("Rational Choice Under Certainty"), Palgrave-McMillan. [ariel]
  • Zahle, J., & Kincaid, H. (2019) "Why Be a Methodological Individualist?", Synthese, 196: 655-675. [library]
    2. Games
  • Guala, F. (2016) Understanding Institutions, Princeton University Press, Ch. 1-2 [ariel]
    3. Dilemmas of cooperation
  • Peterson, M. (ed. 2015) The Prisoner's Dilemma. Cambridge University Press (Introduction). [ariel, library]
  • Handout on Repeated Games [ariel].
  • Kuhn, S. (2019) "Prisoner's Dilemma", Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/prisoner-dilemma/ [online]
    4. Coordination and convention
  • Lewis, D. (1969) Convention. Blackwell, selected paragraphs from Chs. 1 and 2. [S&G, ariel, library]
  • Schelling, T. C. (1957) "Bargaining, Communication, and Limited War", Conflict Resolution 1, 19-36. [library]
    5. Unfair conventions
  • O'Connor, C. (2019) The Origins of Unfairness, Oxford University Press, Ch. 2 ("Social Categories, Coordination, and Inequity") [ariel]
  • Cudd, A. E. (1994). "Oppression by Choice", Journal of Social Philosophy 25, 22-44 [online].
    6. Social norms
  • Bicchieri, C. (2006) The Grammar of Society, Cambridge University Press, Ch. 1 ("The rules we live by"). [S&G, ariel]
  • Camerer, C. F., & Fehr, E. (2004) "Measuring social norms and preferences using experimental games: A guide for social scientists", in J. Henrich et al (eds.) Foundations of Human Sociality, Oxford University Press. [There are various pre-print versions online, e.g. http://www.econ.uzh.ch/static/wp_iew/iewwp097.pdf]
  • Kölle, F. & Quercia, S. (2021) "The Influence of Empirical and Normative Expectations on Cooperation", Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 190: 691-703 [library]
    7. Groups
  • Okasha, S., (2013) "Biological Altruism", Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2013/entries/altruism-biological/ [online]
  • Sterelny, K. (2021). "The origins of multi-level society". Topoi, 40(1), 207-220. [library]
  • Dubreuil, B. (2008). "Strong reciprocity and the emergence of large-scale societies". Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 38(2), 192-210. [library]
  • Harwick, C. (2018). "Money and its institutional substitutes: the role of exchange institutions in human cooperation". Journal of Institutional Economics, 14, 689-714. [online]
    9. Collective intentionality
  • Gilbert, M. (1990) "Walking Together: A Paradigmatic Social Phenomenon", Midwest Studies in Philosophy 15: pp. 1-14. [ariel, online]
  • Gold, N. & Sugden, R. (2007) "Theories of Team Agency", in F. Peter & H.B. Schmidt (eds.) Rationality and Commitment, Oxford University Press. [online]
  • Gilbert, M. (2006) "Rationality in Collective Action", Philosophy of the Social Sciences, 36: 3-17. [library]
    10. Constitutive rules
  • Searle, J. (2005) "What Is an Institution?", Journal of Institutional Economics 1: 1-22 [online].
  • Searle, J. (1990) "Collective Intentions and Actions." In Intentions in Communication, edited by P. Cohen, J. Morgan, and M. E. Pollack. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, pp. 401-415. [ariel, free online].
  • Smit, J. P., Buekens, F., and du Plessis, S. (2011) "What is Money? An Alternative to Searle's Institutional Facts." Economics and Philosophy 27: 1-22. [library]
    11. Rules and equilibria
  • * Guala, F. and Hindriks, F. (2015) "A Unified Social Ontology", Philosophical Quarterly 165 (2015): 177-201. [library]
  • - Searle, J. R. (2015) "Status Functions and Institutional Facts: Reply to Hindriks and Guala." Journal of Institutional Economics 11: 507-514. [library]
  • Hindriks, F., & Guala, F. (2015) "Understanding Institutions: Replies to Aoki, Binmore, Hodgson, Searle, Smith, and Sugden". Journal of Institutional Economics 11: 515-22. [library]
    12. Commitment
  • * Michael, J (2022) The Philosophy and Psychology of Commitment, Routledge (Ch. 1-2) [online]
    13. A Comparative Perspective:
    Norms and institutions among non-human animals? (Reading TBD)
    PART 2 (weeks 8-10)
    The second part of the module will be devoted to group work and presentations. Using the concepts and theories acquired in Part 1, we shall address a hot topic in contemporary societies: What is the institution of marriage? Should it be limited to heterosexual couples or should it become more inclusive? Is marriage an outdated institution and should we do without it?

Modalità d'esame

Gli studenti che frequentano almeno il 70% delle lezioni saranno valutati sulla base di un breve elaborato (3000 parole) e di una presentazione. Gli studenti non frequentanti dovranno scrivere un breve documento (3000 parole) e sostenere un esame orale. Criteri di valutazione:
(A) la conoscenza degli argomenti principali del corso;
(B) la capacità di integrare analisi concettuale e metodologie sperimentali e di padroneggiare la letteratura in materia;
(C) l'indipendenza di giudizio rispetto a questioni filosofiche e scientifiche
(D) la capacità di fornire argomentazioni solide in comunicazioni scritte e orali.

Testi di riferimento

Textbooks and anthologies (NON compulsory):
There are several excellent textbooks of philosophy of social science, which do not cover all the topics of this module, but which may be useful as background readings and bibliographic resources:
· Risjord, M. (2014) Philosophy of Social Science: A Contemporary Introduction. Routledge.
· Rosenberg, A. (2012) Philosophy of Social Science. Westview/Routledge, 4th edition.
These anthologies collect classic papers:
· Steel, D. & Guala, F. (eds. 2011) The Philosophy of Social Science Reader. Routledge. [S&G]
· Martin, M. and McIntyre, L. (eds. 1994) Readings in the Philosophy of Social Science. MIT Press. [M&M]
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (https://plato.stanford.edu/) is another valuable resource for background material, see for example the entries on "Methodological Individualism", "Instrumental Rationality", "Social Norms", "Convention", "Evolutionary Game Theory", "Biological Altruism", "Social Ontology", "Social Institutions", "Collective Intentionality", and more.
Finally, you may also find these handbooks useful:
· Jarvie, I. and Zamora Bonilla, J. (eds. 2011) The Sage Handbook of the Philosophy of Social Sciences. London: Sage.
· Kincaid, H. (ed. 2012) The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Social Science. Oxford University Press.
· Cartwright, N. & Montuschi, E. (eds. 2014) Philosophy of Social Science. Oxford University Press.
Part 2
Girgis, S., George, R. P., & Anderson, R. T. (2011). "What Is Marriage". Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy, 34, 245-88. [online]
Gallagher, M. (2009). "Prepared Statement of Maggie Gallagher". Drake Law Review, 58, 889-903. [online]
Mercier, A. (2007). "Meaning and Necessity: Can Semantics Stop Same-sex Marriage?". Essays in Philosophy, 8, 142-181. [online]
Koppelman, A. (2004) "The Decline and Fall or The Case Against Same-sex Marriage". University of St Thomas Law Journal, 2, 5-32. [online]
Sunstein, C. R., & Thaler, R. H. (2008). "Privatizing Marriage". The Monist, 91, 377-387. [library]
Chambers, C. (2013, July). "The Marriage-free State". In Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, 113, 123-143. [online, library]

Codice insegnamento rationality-rules-and-institutions

The politics of mobility, displacement and asylum 1° anno · 1° semestre · 6 CFU · SDEA-01/A · 0 file

The course belongs to the general area of political anthropology and the related sub-discipline of the anthropology of migration (e.g human mobility, forced displacement, humanitarianism, globalization etc) as well as to…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course belongs to the general area of political anthropology and the related sub-discipline of the anthropology of migration (e.g human mobility, forced displacement, humanitarianism, globalization etc) as well as to studies on citizenship and political inclusion. In the first part, it pre-sents an introduction to global mobility, global migration flows, displacement and asylum, taking into account their quantitative, legal and sociological dimensions and, specifically, it will deal with (global) South-North and South-South mobility and displacement. In the second part, from an anthropological and ethnographic perspective, in-depth case studies around these themes are presented, shedding light on social worlds, experiences, tensions and transformations related to migration. The third part (9 credits only) is a seminar-style section focused on developing a politi-cal anthropology of citizenship, asylum, political inclusion, nationalism, belonging, community-making: it presents and discusses classical texts as well as new research revolving around these topics.

Knowledge and UnderstandingThrough a combination of lectures, individual/group presentations and classroom discussions, by the end of the course students will be able to:1. Critically discuss key issues relating to human mobility, global migration flows, asylum and dis-placement in their quantitative and qualitative dimensions.2. Analyse detailed case studies, with context-specific and ethnographically documented exam-ples.3. Understand how the definitions of migrant, refugee and citizen; political exclusion and inclu-sion; statelessness, citizenship and national belonging are co-defined.Ability to apply knowledge and understanding1. Assess the political, policy and ethical implications of migration dynamics and the public dis-courses constructed around them.2. Go beyond generic and stereotypical representations of migration, belonging and citizenship, differentiating between types, categories and dimensions of migration.3. Go beyond the ethnocentric view of globalisation and migration dynamics.

Programma

The course consists of Part 1 and Part 2 (six credits) supplemented by Part 3 (9-credits course only).
For PPPA students: 6 credit is the norm, the 9 credits option available only as "Free credits" the exception.
For Philosophical Sciences, Erasmus or other MA courses: both options, 6 or 9 credits, are available if allowed by your study plan.
The course presents a reflection on the contemporary tensions between globalization, human mobility, nation-states, and the creation of borders, considered at the heart of the current production of political identities and forms of citizenship. Its basic aims are to give a solid introduction to the global processes of human mobility, displacement and asylum and to offer, in part 2, a thorough analysis of specific case-studies from the perspective of political anthropology and ethnographic field-research.
Part 1. An introduction to the main elements and debates related to contemporary global migration dynamics:
South-North migration; categories, theories, policies, global dynamics; refugees and asylum; forced and irregularized migration.
Part 2. Understanding irregular migration and containment policies, from Africa to Europe:
through a series of case studies, this part will analyze the forms and motivations of irregular migration from Africa to Europe in an anthropological and historical perspective. In the background, this section addresses the dynamics related to forced displacement, refugees, and irregular migrants on the borders of Europe, analyzing the forms of containment and governance of forced displacement, with particular attention to cases of protracted crisis and the transformation of the regimes of mobility over time, between asylum and irregular mobility.
The course consists of Part 1 and Part 2 (six credits) supplemented by Part 3 (9-credits course only).
For PPPA students: 6 credit is the norm, the 9 credits option available only as "Free credits" the exception.
For Philosophical Sciences, Erasmus or other MA courses: both options, 6 or 9 credits, are available if allowed by your study plan.
The course presents a reflection on the contemporary tensions between globalization, human mobility, nation-states, and the creation of borders, considered at the heart of the current production of political identities and forms of citizenship. Its basic aims are to give a solid introduction to the global processes of human mobility, displacement and asylum and to offer, in part 2, a thorough analysis of specific case-studies from the perspective of political anthropology and ethnographic field-research.
Part 1. An introduction to the main elements and debates related to contemporary global migration dynamics:
South-North migration; categories, theories, policies, global dynamics; refugees and asylum; forced and irregularized migration.
Part 2. Understanding irregular migration and containment policies, from Africa to Europe:
through a series of case studies, this part will analyze the forms and motivations of irregular migration from Africa to Europe in an anthropological and historical perspective. In the background, this section addresses the dynamics related to forced displacement, refugees, and irregular migrants on the borders of Europe, analyzing the forms of containment and governance of forced displacement, with particular attention to cases of protracted crisis and the transformation of the regimes of mobility over time, between asylum and irregular mobility.
Part 3 (9 credits only). A Political Anthropology of Asylum, Refugees and Citizenship: This seminar-style section will reflect, this year, on the production of political identities within the context of nation-states, on their colonial legacies, on postcolonial political violence and its possible way-outs, on the recurrent production of mass displacement and minorities. Specifically, it will provide a reflection on how the categories of citizen, foreigner, settler and native are made in contemporary political global panorama by analyzing the book of Mohammed Mamdani "Neither Settler nor Native: The Making and Unmaking of Permanent Minorities". Students are asked to study Introduction and Conclusion (chapter 6) and on of the case studies presented in the book (Chapter 1 The Indian Question in the United States; Chapter 2 Nuremberg: The Failure of Denazification; Chapter 3 Settlers and Natives in Apartheid South Africa; Chapter 4 Sudan: Colonialism, Independence, and Secession; Chapter 5 The Israel / Palestine Question). Classroom lectures will follow a similar structure.
Classroom lectures will involve reading, writing, discussion, presentations.
Classroom lectures will involve reading, writing, discussion, presentations.

Modalità d'esame

Oral exam assessing students' knowledge of the key topics of the course, theoretical frameworks and methodologies, familiarity with technical and scientific terms.

Testi di riferimento

The list of texts indicated below is provisional and will be confirmed before the beginning of classes:
Part 1: Global migration dynamics
Hein de Haas, Stephen Castles, Mark J. Miller,
The Age of Migration : International Population Movements in the Modern World, Bloomsbury Publishing Plc, 2019, - ONLY Chapters 1, 2, 3, 4, 10, 11, 14, 15)
Part 2:
5 out of 8 articles of the Volume 18, Issue 1 (2024) of the Journal of Eastern African Studies titled "Fragments of solidarity : the social worlds of African migrants moving northwards" https://www.tandfonline.com/toc/rjea20/18/1
(Most of the texts of part 1 and 2 will be made available to students during class).
Part 3:
Mahmood Mamdani, Neither Settler nor Native: The Making and Unmaking of Permanent Minorities, Harvard University Press, 2020 - chapters 1, 6, and ONE of your choice among ch. 2 to 5.
(edizione italiana: Né coloni né nativi. Lo stato-nazione e le sue minoranze permanenti, Meltemi, 2023.

Codice insegnamento politics-mobility-displacement-and-asylum-0

The western tradition: moral and political values 1° anno · 12 CFU · PHIL-05/A · 0 file

The course aims at introducing the students to the moral and political values prominent in the Western tradition. A selection of values (such as liberty, autonomy, equality, fairness, fraternity, solidarity, critique,…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course aims at introducing the students to the moral and political values prominent in the Western tradition. A selection of values (such as liberty, autonomy, equality, fairness, fraternity, solidarity, critique, limitation of power..) and issues connected with them will be presented and analyzed in order to teach the students how to recognize when they are at stake, when they conflict with each other and how to critically assess the possible solutions and policies dealing with these values. At the end of the course, the students must be able to evaluate social and political issues in the light of the main moral and political values and to envisage the justification for the choices concerning them.

The expected learning outcomes include: - The knowledge and understanding of the meaning and the practical implications of the main moral and political values in the Western tradition-The ability to apply the knowledge and understanding of these values to the issues raised by the conflict among the values themselves and by typical contemporary social problems-The ability to analyse and evaluate critically real life situations taken from the recent history of moral and political discussion-The skill to communicate and argue in favour and against some values in specific situations, identifying themselves with one or another of the different opinions concerning the issue at stake in a discussion with the colleagues and the teacher (debate method)-The ability to read, understand, summarize and communicate the content of chapters and articles concerning the moral and political values discussed, obtained through the reading and exposition in the classroom, guided by the teacher (flipped classroom method)

Programma

UNIT 1
Unit 1: Moral and Political Progress
Course syllabus
1. What is a Moral and Political Value?
2. "Western" and "European" Values
3. The Concept of Progress: A Look into the History of Ideas
4. R. Koselleck, "'Progress' and 'Decline'. An Appendix to the History of Two Concepts"
5. Enlightenment and Moral Progress
6. I. Kant, "An Answer to the Question: What is Enlightenment?" (1784)
7. Kand and Progress as Reflective Judgement
8. I. Kant, "Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Aim" (1784)
9. Hegel and Progress as Historical Fact
10. G.W.F. Hegel, "Lectures on the Philosophy of World History" (excerpts) (1830)
11. Marx on Progress
12. K. Marx, "A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy" (excerpts) (1859)
13. Nietzsche and Progress as Decadence
14. Friedrich Nietzsche, "On the Genealogy of Morality" (excerpts) (1883)
15. The Frankfurt School on Progress: Benjamin and Adorno
16. T.W. Adorno, M. Horkheimer, "Dialectic of the Enlightenment" (excerpts) (1947)
17. Progress and Colonialism
18. D. Chakrabarty, "The Idea of Provincializing Europe" (excerpts) (2000)
19. Contemporary Debates on Progress in Analytic Philosophy
20. Contemporary Debates on Progress in Critical Theory
Please note: The syllabus will be fine-tuned at the beginning of the course. The final version of the syllabus, completed with more precise bibliographical indications and suggestions for papers and presentations, will be available on the Ariel website of the course
UNIT 2
Political and Moral Freedom
Course syllabus:
1. Constant's view of ancient and modern freedom (2 hours).
2. Some forms of modern freedom: Hobbes, Rousseau and Mill (2 hours)
3. Berlin's traditional distinction and beyond (2hours)
4. The neo-Roman view of freedom as independence from arbitrary power (3 hours)
5. The neo-republican view of freedom as non-domination (3 hours)
6. Hegel's idea of concrete freedom (2 hours)
7. Marx's view of freedom (2 hours)
8. Honneth's view of social freedom (3 hours)
9. Freedom as intellectual autonomy: Kant and Foucault on critique (2 hours)
10. Foucault's view of freedom and power (3 hours)
11. Sartre's existential freedom (2 hours)
12. 'One is not born, but becomes, a woman': Simone de Beauvoir's view of freedom (2 hours)
13. Feminisms and freedom (2 hours)
14. Arendt's idea of freedom as the raison d'être of politics (3 hours)
15. Towards a postcolonial view of freedom: Louverture and Fanon (2 hours)
16. Freedom and subalternity: can the subaltern speak? (3 hours)
17. Freedom as a contested concept (2 hours).
Please note: The syllabus will be fine-tuned at the beginning of the course. The final version of the syllabus, completed with more precise bibliographical indications and suggestions for papers and presentations, will be available on the Ariel website of the course

Modalità d'esame

UNIT 1
Attendant students are required to read the assigned materials during the course and to participate actively in the discussion of the texts. Also, the students have to show, in the final colloquium, that they have read and understood all the assigned texts and that they can argue on relevant issues using the concepts, the knowledge and the theories that have been presented and used in the course.
The assessment is based on an oral colloquium, and it includes the evaluation of the active role played by each student (through short presentations of the texts, participation in the discussion, offering arguments and cases, raising objections to the theories) during the course.
For non-attendant students, evaluation is based on an oral colloquium.
The criteria for assessment are:
1. Adequate and complete knowledge of the contents and the material of the course
2. Adequate language in the use of moral concepts and theories
3. Clarity of exposition in the presentations and in answering the questions
4. Capacity to re-elaborate the contents in order to face problematic issues in morally and politically relevant situations
The mark is assigned in 30/30
Unit 2
Attendant students are required to read the assigned materials during the course and to participate actively in the discussion of the texts. Also, the students have to show, in the final colloquium, that they have read and understood all the assigned texts and that they can argue on relevant issues using the concepts, the knowledge and the theories that have been presented and used in the course.
The assessment is based on an oral colloquium and it includes the evaluation of the active role played by each student (through short presentations of the texts and participation in class discussion) during the course (up to 3/30).
For non-attendant students, evaluation is based on an oral colloquium (maximum mark: 30)
The criteria for assessment are:
1. Adequate and complete knowledge of the contents and the material of the course
2. Adequate language in the use of moral concepts and theories
3. Clarity of exposition in the presentations and in answering the questions
4. Capacity to re-elaborate the contents in order to face problematic issues in morally and politically relevant situations
The mark is assigned in 30/30

Testi di riferimento

UNIT 1
Teaching Resources

  • Adorno, T.W. and Horkheimer, M., 2002. Dialectic of Enlightenment: Philosophical Fragments. Translated by E.F.N. Jephcott. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
  • Hegel, G.W.F., 1975. Lectures on the Philosophy of World History. Translated by H.B. Nisbet. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (Originally delivered 1857)
  • Kant, I., 1996. 'An Answer to the Question: What is Enlightenment? (1784)'. In: M.J. Gregor, ed. Practical Philosophy. The Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.11-22.
  • Kant, I., 2005. 'Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Aim'. Translated by A. Wood. In: A.O. Rorty and J. Schmidt, eds. Kant's Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Aim: A Critical Guide. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. (Originally published 1784)
  • Koselleck, R., 2002. '"Progress" and "Decline". An Appendix to the History of Two Concepts'. In: The Practice of Conceptual History: Timing History, Spacing Concepts. Translated by T.S. Presner. Stanford: Stanford University Press, pp.218-235.
  • Marx, K., 1970. A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy. Translated by N.I. Stone. New York: International Publishers. (Originally published 1859)
  • Nietzsche, F., 1998. On the Genealogy of Morality. Translated by M. Clark and A. Swensen. Indianapolis: Hackett. (Originally published 1887)
    Further readings
  • Adorno, T.W., 2005. 'Progress'. In: Critical Models: Interventions and Catchwords. Translated by H. Pickford. New York: Columbia University Press.
  • Allen, A., 2016. The End of Progress: Decolonizing the Normative Foundations of Critical Theory. New York: Columbia University Press.
  • Benjamin, W., 1969. 'Theses on the Philosophy of History'. In: H. Arendt, ed. Illuminations. Translated by H. Zohn. New York: Schocken, pp.253-264. (Originally published 1940)
  • Forst, R., 2017. 'The Concept of Progress'. In: Normativity and Power: Analyzing Social Orders of Justification. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  • Foucault, M., 1977. 'Nietzsche, Genealogy, History'. In: D.F. Bouchard, ed. Language, Counter-Memory, Practice: Selected Essays and Interviews. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
  • Jaeggi, R., 2025. Progress and Regression. Translated by R. Savage. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
  • McCarthy, T., 2009. Race, Empire, and the Idea of Human Development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  • Møller, S., 2021. 'Kant on Non-Linear Progress'. Ethics & Politics, 23, pp.127-147.
  • Sauer, H., et al., 2021. 'Moral Progress: Recent Developments'. Philosophy Compass, 16(10), e12769.
    UNIT 2
    Teaching Resources
    -W.B. Gallie, Essentially Contested Concepts, in «Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society», New Series, vol. 56 (1955-56), pp. 167-198
  • Anthology: selected passages from the works of Hobbes (Leviathan), Rousseau (The Social Contract), Kant (What Is Enlightenment?), François-Dominique Toussaint Louverture (Refutations), Hegel (Lectures on the Philosophy of History), Marx (On the Jewish Question), Mill (On Liberty), Fanon (The Wretched of the Earth) and Berlin (Two Concepts of Liberty) will all be available on the Ariel website for this course.
    -B. Constant, The Liberty of Ancients Compared with that of Moderns, Online Library of Liberty
    -Q. Skinner, A Third Concept of Liberty, in «Proceedings of the British Academy», 117 (2002), pp. 237-268
    -P. Pettit, Freedom, in D. Estlund (ed. by), The Oxford Handbook of Political Philosophy, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2012, chapter 4
    -J.P. Sartre, Existentialism is a Humanism, New Haven, Yale University Press, 2007
    -M. Foucault, The subject and Power, in «Critical Inquiry», Vol. 8, No. 4, Summer, 1982, pp. 777-795
    -H. Arendt, What is freedom?, in Ead., Between Past and Future, The Viking Press, New York 1961, pp. 143-172
    -A. Honneth, Three, Not Two, Concepts of Liberty: A Proposal to Enlarge Our Moral Self-Understanding, in R. Zuckert and J. Kreines (eds), Hegel on Philosophy in History, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2017, pp. 177-192
    -G.C. Spivak, Can the subaltern speak?, in R. C. Morris, Can the subaltern speak? Reflections on the history of an idea, New York, Columbia University Press, 2010, pp. 21-80.
    -S. de Beauvoir, Introduction, in Ead., The secondo Sex, New York, Vintage Book, 2010
    Suggested readings for non attending students:
    T. Tömmel and M. Passerin d'Entreves, Hannah Arendt, in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. by E. N. Zalta and U. Nodelman, https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2025/entries/arendt.
    G. Gutting and J. Oksala, Michel Foucault, in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. by E. N. Zalta and U. Nodelman, https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2022/entries/foucault/
  • J. Jennings, Constant's Idea of Modern Liberty, In H. Rosenblatt (ed), The Cambridge Companion to Constant, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2009, pp. 69-91.
    F. Lovett, Republicanism", in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, ed. by E. N. Zalta and U. Nodelman, https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2022/entries/republicanism
    -M. Bevir, The Contextual Approach, in G. Klosko (ed. by), The Oxford Handbook of the History of Political Philosophy, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011
    -N. Hirschmann, Feminism, in G. Klosko (ed. by), The Oxford Handbook of the History of Political Philosophy, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2011
    Please, note: these are optional readings and therefore they will not be the subject of questions during the final oral examination

Codice insegnamento western-tradition-moral-and-political-values

Additional language skills: italian (3 ECTS) 2° anno · 3 CFU · 0 file

A2: Attaining the A2 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for languages (CEFR)B1: Attaining the B1 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for languages (CEFR)B2:…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

A2: Attaining the A2 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for languages (CEFR)B1: Attaining the B1 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for languages (CEFR)B2: Attaining the B2 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for languages (CEFR)

Reading comprehensionA2: reading very short and simple texts and find specific, predictable information in simple everyday material such as advertisements, menus and timetables; understanding short and simple personal letters.B1: understanding texts that consist mainly of high frequency everyday or job-related language. Understanding the description of events, feelings and wishes in personal letters.B2: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems in which the writers adopt particular attitudes or viewpoints. Understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehensionA2: understanding phrases and the most common words related to family, shopping, local geography; understanding the main elements in short, clear, simple messages and announcements.B1: understanding the main points of clear standard speech on familiar matters regularly encountered in work, school, leisure, etc. Understanding the main point of many radio or TV programmes on current affairs or topics of personal or professional interest when the delivery is relatively slow and clear.B2: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex lines of argument provided the topic is reasonably familiar. Understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes. Understanding the majority of films in standard dialect.

Programma

Reading comprehensionA2: reading very short and simple texts and find specific, predictable information in simple everyday material such as advertisements, menus and timetables; understanding short and simple personal letters.B1: understanding texts that consist mainly of high frequency everyday or job-related language. Understanding the description of events, feelings and wishes in personal letters.B2: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems in which the writers adopt particular attitudes or viewpoints. Understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehensionA2: understanding phrases and the most common words related to family, shopping, local geography; understanding the main elements in short, clear, simple messages and announcements.B1: understanding the main points of clear standard speech on familiar matters regularly encountered in work, school, leisure, etc. Understanding the main point of many radio or TV programmes on current affairs or topics of personal or professional interest when the delivery is relatively slow and clear.B2: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex lines of argument provided the topic is reasonably familiar. Understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes. Understanding the majority of films in standard dialect.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: TestGiudizio di valutazione: livello raggiunto

Codice insegnamento additional-language-skills-italian-3-ects

Advanced language skills: french (3 ECTS) 2° anno · 3 CFU · 0 file

Attaining B2 level according to the he Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR). Reading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding contemporary…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

Attaining B2 level according to the he Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR).

Reading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehension: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex arguments as long as the topic is reasonably familiar; understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes in a standard languageReading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehension: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex arguments as long as the topic is reasonably familiar; understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes in a standard Language

Programma

Reading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehension: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex arguments as long as the topic is reasonably familiar; understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes in a standard languageReading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehension: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex arguments as long as the topic is reasonably familiar; understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes in a standard Language

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: TestGiudizio di valutazione: livello raggiunto

Codice insegnamento advanced-language-skills-french-3-ects

Advanced language skills: german (3 ECTS) 2° anno · 3 CFU · 0 file

Attaining B1 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) Reading comprehension: understanding texts that consist mainly of high frequency everyday language; understanding the…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

Attaining B1 level according to the Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR)

Reading comprehension: understanding texts that consist mainly of high frequency everyday language; understanding the description of events, feelings and wishes in personal letters.Listening comprehension: understanding the main points of clear standard speech on familiar matters; understanding the main points of many radio or TV programmes on current affairs or topics of personal interest as long as the delivery is relatively slow and clear.

Programma

Reading comprehension: understanding texts that consist mainly of high frequency everyday language; understanding the description of events, feelings and wishes in personal letters.Listening comprehension: understanding the main points of clear standard speech on familiar matters; understanding the main points of many radio or TV programmes on current affairs or topics of personal interest as long as the delivery is relatively slow and clear.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: TestGiudizio di valutazione: livello raggiunto

Codice insegnamento advanced-language-skills-german-3-ects

Advanced language skills: spanish (3 ECTS) 2° anno · 3 CFU · 0 file

Attaining the B2 level according to the he Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR) Reading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

Attaining the B2 level according to the he Common European Framework of Reference for Languages (CEFR)

Reading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehension: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex arguments as long as the topic is familiar; understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes in a standard language.

Programma

Reading comprehension: reading articles and reports concerned with contemporary problems; understanding contemporary literary prose.Listening comprehension: understanding extended speech and lectures and follow even complex arguments as long as the topic is familiar; understanding most TV news and current affairs programmes in a standard language.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: TestGiudizio di valutazione: livello raggiunto

Codice insegnamento advanced-language-skills-spanish-3-ects

Climate change: ethics and politics 2° anno · 6 CFU · PHIL-03/A · 0 file

The primary goal of the course is to teach students the method of philosophical reflection in this field, which involves:- identifying an environmental problem and accurately describing it from a scientific point of…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The primary goal of the course is to teach students the method of philosophical reflection in this field, which involves:- identifying an environmental problem and accurately describing it from a scientific point of view;- reflecting on the distribution of responsibility, both in terms of having caused the problem (backward-looking responsibility) and in terms of being able to solve or address it (forward-looking responsibility);- identifying the agents who can or should intervene—whether individuals, institutions, or both;- developing a moral theory capable of solidly justifying the attribution of responsibility to the identified agents.

By the end of the course, students will have acquired basic competencies regarding some of the key issues addressed in environmental ethics, such as climate change; the role and capacity of institutions to manage it effectively; what individuals may be called upon to do; and on what moral grounds such expectations can be based.

Programma

By the end of the course, students will have acquired basic competencies regarding some of the key issues addressed in environmental ethics, such as climate change; the role and capacity of institutions to manage it effectively; what individuals may be called upon to do; and on what moral grounds such expectations can be based.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento climate-change-ethics-and-politics-0

Differences and non-discrimination: rights in action 2° anno · 6 CFU · GIUR-04/A · 0 file

This course provides the theoretical and analytical tools necessary for engaging with strategic litigation on non-discrimination and equal opportunities. Starting from the general principles of the international,…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

This course provides the theoretical and analytical tools necessary for engaging with strategic litigation on non-discrimination and equal opportunities. Starting from the general principles of the international, European and domestic legal order, the course will analyse the linkages between the Rule of law, equality, dignity and fundamental rights. The course will explain which are the protected grounds of discrimination and which are considered, on the contrary, legitimate differences in treatment. The course will focus on the protected grounds of nationality, ethnic origin, sex, sexual orientation, disability, age and religion and will approach to the issues related to the implementation of the principle of equality through the analisys of caselaw. The concepts of direct, indirect and multiple discrimination will be analysed in detail, together with the scope of anti-discrimination law and its limits. Furthermore, the course aims at acquiring the knowledge and skills required to be able to maintain an adequate update over time on the evolution of the institutional framework.

The expected learning outcomes are knowledge and understanding of the principles of equality and equal opportunities in global societies, and the protection of human dignity through anti-discrimination laws that aim to achieve them. Students will learn to frame individual cases within the legal order, and to identify the rules applicable to the specific case-law examined, through a correct application in the legal field of the techniques of problem solving. Students will also learn to express autonomous assessments on the regulatory system and on the effects of rules on the equality and dignity of those groups who are discriminated against. They will learn how to work in a group through activities carried out both in the classroom and autonomously , with the aim of developing relational and communication skills.

Programma

The expected learning outcomes are knowledge and understanding of the principles of equality and equal opportunities in global societies, and the protection of human dignity through anti-discrimination laws that aim to achieve them. Students will learn to frame individual cases within the legal order, and to identify the rules applicable to the specific case-law examined, through a correct application in the legal field of the techniques of problem solving. Students will also learn to express autonomous assessments on the regulatory system and on the effects of rules on the equality and dignity of those groups who are discriminated against. They will learn how to work in a group through activities carried out both in the classroom and autonomously , with the aim of developing relational and communication skills.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento differences-and-non-discrimination-rights-action-0

Dirty-hands politics: theories and practices 2° anno · 6 CFU · GSPS-01/A · 0 file

"Dirty Hands Politics" in general refers to the idea that the right political action can conflict with profound morality. From a Machiavellian perspective, political responsibility rests on the availability to dirt one's…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

"Dirty Hands Politics" in general refers to the idea that the right political action can conflict with profound morality. From a Machiavellian perspective, political responsibility rests on the availability to dirt one's hands, to endorse morally reprehensible means in order to achieve valuable ends. The first part the course introduces students to the controversial nature of the dirty hands dilemma as it is closely linked to the concepts of morality and responsibility. The main aim here is to offer, through the notion of dirty hands and the evaluation of the means-ends problem, a deeper understanding about political responsibility, about the ethics of political leadership and about the implications connected to political decisions, especially in times of trouble. The second part the course will explore the main philosophical reflections on the nature of torture - its causes, aims, and forms. By the end of this course students will be able to provide a clearer definition of the relationship between politics and morality; to better understand why dirty-hands' practices occurs, how they operate, and what are the consequences of reacting in different ways to certain types of DH. More in details, this course intends:- to equip students with an introductory knowledge of the dirty-hands question;- to deepen students' understanding of major ethical problems and concepts by applying those systems and concepts to the issue of dirty hands;- to equip students with the skills for engaging in the process of making ethical judgments and defending them in speech and writing;- to further cultivate student's own intellectual and moral virtues by calling them to engage in moral reflection on the means-ends problem.

In the framework of the PPPA degree, at the end of the course, students will have obtained knowledge of some of the most central questions and positions in contemporary debates about the dirty-hands problem:- Do "good" and "evil" mean the same in theory and in practice?- What is torture and can it ever be morally justified?- What can we learn about torture and terrorism from the history of the social and political theo-ries?-What are the limits and possibilities of contemporary practices in "the war against terror"?- How should torture be situated in a wider social and cultural context?In terms of skills, students will:- learn to interpret, analyze and critically discuss scholarly texts, official documents and cultural representations with a view to their possible implications for social and political practices;- learn to compare and evaluate moral, political and legal ideals and proposals.In terms of competence, students will:- enhance their capability to question and discuss urgent and sensitive aspects of the dirty-hands problem;- enhance their capability to formulate and reflect on their own ideas of the legitimacy of means and ends in the (in)security state.

Programma

In the framework of the PPPA degree, at the end of the course, students will have obtained knowledge of some of the most central questions and positions in contemporary debates about the dirty-hands problem:- Do "good" and "evil" mean the same in theory and in practice?- What is torture and can it ever be morally justified?- What can we learn about torture and terrorism from the history of the social and political theo-ries?-What are the limits and possibilities of contemporary practices in "the war against terror"?- How should torture be situated in a wider social and cultural context?In terms of skills, students will:- learn to interpret, analyze and critically discuss scholarly texts, official documents and cultural representations with a view to their possible implications for social and political practices;- learn to compare and evaluate moral, political and legal ideals and proposals.In terms of competence, students will:- enhance their capability to question and discuss urgent and sensitive aspects of the dirty-hands problem;- enhance their capability to formulate and reflect on their own ideas of the legitimacy of means and ends in the (in)security state.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento dirty-hands-politics-theories-and-practices-0

Final exam 2° anno · 15 CFU · 0 file

The final exam consists in writing a Master's dissertation, in publicly presenting it and in discussing it with the members of the examining Commission. The Master's dissertation is expected to constitute an original…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The final exam consists in writing a Master's dissertation, in publicly presenting it and in discussing it with the members of the examining Commission. The Master's dissertation is expected to constitute an original piece of scientific work, it must focus on topics selected from those addressed by PPPA's courses and it must be prepared under the guidance of a supervisor. The main objective of the final exam is to strengthen students' familiarity with the peculiar requirements of scientific research and writing. The final exam is also intended to provide students with the opportunity to conduct autonomous research on themes and questions in line with their specific research interests.

Knowledge and understanding:By collecting and examining material for writing the Master's dissertation, students are expected to acquire a broad and clear understanding about the topic on which their dissertation focuses and to consolidate their knowledge concerning the selected topic and other related themes. Applying knowledge and understanding:The process of writing the dissertation is expected to prompt students to apply methodological competences and substantive knowledge acquired during the Master's program in order to address the selected topic in properly scientific terms and to frame it with reference to a rich theoretical background.Making judgements:The Master's dissertation is expected to be an original piece of scientific work. Accordingly, students are expected to improve their capacity to autonomously evaluate which sources of evidence or which references are authoritative and which are relevant with respect to the selected topic. Students are also expected to refine their ability to develop autonomous judgments about the scientific debate concerning their selected topic and to propose original interpretations, analyses and arguments. Communication:By working on the Master's dissertation, students are expected to acquire high familiarity with the style of scientific writing and to improve their capacities to devise a linear argumentative strategy and a consistent research design apt to address the questions relevant to the selected topic. Students are also expected to strengthen their writing skills and their capacity to provide clear summaries of complex arguments, analyses or debates as well as the capacity to communicate in an effective and accessible way the outcomes of their research. By publicly discussing the Master's dissertation, students will have a further opportunity to exercise and reinforce their communication skills and their ability to persuasively present and convincingly defend their arguments and their analyses.

Programma

Knowledge and understanding:By collecting and examining material for writing the Master's dissertation, students are expected to acquire a broad and clear understanding about the topic on which their dissertation focuses and to consolidate their knowledge concerning the selected topic and other related themes. Applying knowledge and understanding:The process of writing the dissertation is expected to prompt students to apply methodological competences and substantive knowledge acquired during the Master's program in order to address the selected topic in properly scientific terms and to frame it with reference to a rich theoretical background.Making judgements:The Master's dissertation is expected to be an original piece of scientific work. Accordingly, students are expected to improve their capacity to autonomously evaluate which sources of evidence or which references are authoritative and which are relevant with respect to the selected topic. Students are also expected to refine their ability to develop autonomous judgments about the scientific debate concerning their selected topic and to propose original interpretations, analyses and arguments. Communication:By working on the Master's dissertation, students are expected to acquire high familiarity with the style of scientific writing and to improve their capacities to devise a linear argumentative strategy and a consistent research design apt to address the questions relevant to the selected topic. Students are also expected to strengthen their writing skills and their capacity to provide clear summaries of complex arguments, analyses or debates as well as the capacity to communicate in an effective and accessible way the outcomes of their research. By publicly discussing the Master's dissertation, students will have a further opportunity to exercise and reinforce their communication skills and their ability to persuasively present and convincingly defend their arguments and their analyses.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento final-exam-6

Frontiers in bioethics 2° anno · 6 CFU · PHIL-03/A · 0 file

This course aims to provide an overview of some of the most pressing issues addressed in the contemporary bioethical debate and is structured in four parts. The first part aims to offer a methodological introduction to…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

This course aims to provide an overview of some of the most pressing issues addressed in the contemporary bioethical debate and is structured in four parts. The first part aims to offer a methodological introduction to the discipline and an overview of two classical issues discussed in bioethical reflection, namely, abortion and end-of-life. These notions will serve as a fundamental basis to discuss in detail three of the most pressing topics of bioethics in our nowadays society. Therefore, the second part explores the ethical issues emerging from structural scarcity in healthcare and the necessity to allocate healthcare resources. The third part investigates the ethics of genetics and examines how current and future assisted reproductive technologies may change our understanding of human reproduction. The fourth and final part discusses the ethical problems emerging from the implementation of artificial intelligence in clinical settings, discussing in particular the AI impact on the doctor-patient relationship and end-of-life decisions.

This course will allow students to acquire the knowledge and skills necessary for the development of a critical and non-dogmatic reflection on complex bioethical issues. With regard to knowledge, students will be able to: recognize the aims of bioethical reflection, distinguishing the various areas of practical application of the discipline; recognize the ethical theories and arguments used in dealing with specific bioethical issues. Regarding competencies, students will be able to formulate articulated opinions on the topics covered during the course and present their positions in a coherent and well-argued way.

Programma

This course will allow students to acquire the knowledge and skills necessary for the development of a critical and non-dogmatic reflection on complex bioethical issues. With regard to knowledge, students will be able to: recognize the aims of bioethical reflection, distinguishing the various areas of practical application of the discipline; recognize the ethical theories and arguments used in dealing with specific bioethical issues. Regarding competencies, students will be able to formulate articulated opinions on the topics covered during the course and present their positions in a coherent and well-argued way.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento frontiers-bioethics-0

Global challenges to democracy 2° anno · 6 CFU · GSPS-02/A · 0 file

The course addresses key factors challenging contemporary representative democracies, the causes driving "autocratization", the mechanisms of "democratic backsliding", and both domestic and international factors…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course addresses key factors challenging contemporary representative democracies, the causes driving "autocratization", the mechanisms of "democratic backsliding", and both domestic and international factors undermining the legitimacy of democratic systems. The course also introduces the students to some possible responses that representative institutions and political actors can adopt to strengthen public support for democracy. The course employs the comparative approach, which represents the mainstream method for testing hypotheses in the field of political science, and quantitative techniques for data analysis. Both aggregate-level and individual-level data will be investigated.

By the end of the course, students will be familiar with the analytical tools to study the main threats to contemporary representative democracies and with a range of theoretical and empirical approaches to these problems in the broad field of comparative politics. Students will develop analytical skills in the critical use of data for understanding the social, political, cultural and economic stresses facing democracies across the world and innovatively engaging with these challenges in academic, government and NGO settings.

Programma

By the end of the course, students will be familiar with the analytical tools to study the main threats to contemporary representative democracies and with a range of theoretical and empirical approaches to these problems in the broad field of comparative politics. Students will develop analytical skills in the critical use of data for understanding the social, political, cultural and economic stresses facing democracies across the world and innovatively engaging with these challenges in academic, government and NGO settings.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento global-challenges-democracy-2

Justice and international affairs 2° anno · 6 CFU · GSPS-01/A · 0 file

The course Justice and International Affairs aims to examine the problem of war from a normative perspective, focusing particularly on the framework of just war theory. This theory seeks to de-termine and explain the…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course Justice and International Affairs aims to examine the problem of war from a normative perspective, focusing particularly on the framework of just war theory. This theory seeks to de-termine and explain the normative rules governing the initial resort to war, the conduct of war, and the reconstruction after the war. The primary objective of the course is to develop students' ability to use evaluative language for interpreting and assessing events and actions related to war, which require normative judgment. The central questions explored include: can war be morally justified? Under what conditions? Through a combination of theoretical analysis, presentations, and class discussions, students will learn to critically engage with various normative perspectives and develop their own argumentative abilities.

By the end of the course, students will be able to:1. Explain the complex philosophical and normative questions surrounding war.2. Identify and explain the key differences among major normative approaches to judging war, including political realism, pacifism, and just war theory.3. Critically assess the primary debates within just war theory, including:- The conditions for the permissible initiation of war (jus ad bellum).- The moral duties of combatants during war (jus in bello).- The morality and nature of terrorism.- The permissibility of torture in extreme circumstances.- Moral concerns surrounding recent advances in military technology.- Issues of post-war reconstruction (jus post bellum).4. Construct and critically evaluate normative arguments by providing well-reasoned justifica-tions for specific normative positions concerning war and its related circumstances.5. Investigate particular political issues by debating contrasting and opposite theses on the ba-ses of academic articles or with respect to specific cases.

Programma

By the end of the course, students will be able to:1. Explain the complex philosophical and normative questions surrounding war.2. Identify and explain the key differences among major normative approaches to judging war, including political realism, pacifism, and just war theory.3. Critically assess the primary debates within just war theory, including:- The conditions for the permissible initiation of war (jus ad bellum).- The moral duties of combatants during war (jus in bello).- The morality and nature of terrorism.- The permissibility of torture in extreme circumstances.- Moral concerns surrounding recent advances in military technology.- Issues of post-war reconstruction (jus post bellum).4. Construct and critically evaluate normative arguments by providing well-reasoned justifica-tions for specific normative positions concerning war and its related circumstances.5. Investigate particular political issues by debating contrasting and opposite theses on the ba-ses of academic articles or with respect to specific cases.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento justice-and-international-affairs-0

Neuroethics and human enhancement 2° anno · 6 CFU · PHIL-03/A · 0 file

The aim of the course is to familiarize students with neuroethics enabling them to understand the challenges, the opportunities, and the implications the study of our brain functioning can have on our understanding of…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The aim of the course is to familiarize students with neuroethics enabling them to understand the challenges, the opportunities, and the implications the study of our brain functioning can have on our understanding of ourselves and the world around us. In particular, the course would be structured in two modules dealing with the two branches of neuroethics identified by Roskies (2002): the neuroscience of ethics (a) and the ethics of neuroscience (b). The first one (a) will be devoted to (I) providing the methodological basis to understand how an interdisciplinary field such as neuroethics can and should work; (II) examining the debate on moral judgment, moral decision-making, and moral dilemmas on the basis of philosophical and neuroscientific research (thus, connecting with the course Facts, principles and hard choices); (III) understanding how some of the concepts we currently use both in philosophical debates and in our daily moral, political, legal, and social practice - such as empathy, trust, freedom, and responsibility - should be revised on the basis of the knowledge we have acquired on our brain functioning. The second module (b) will delve into moral and cognitive enhancement made possible by recent technological advancements. The discussion of this possibility will focus on the ethical, social, and political issues it raises.

At the end of the course, students are expected to be familiar with the central issues in neuroethics.In particular, they are expected to: 1)present clearly and have an adequate knowledge of the contents of the course;2)possess the appropriate jargon;3)identify the challenges, opportunities, and implications of the study of our brain functioning from a moral, political, social, and legal point of view;4)have the ability to integrate knowledge in an interdisciplinary way;5) be capable of a personal and original elaboration of the contents discussed.

Programma

At the end of the course, students are expected to be familiar with the central issues in neuroethics.In particular, they are expected to: 1)present clearly and have an adequate knowledge of the contents of the course;2)possess the appropriate jargon;3)identify the challenges, opportunities, and implications of the study of our brain functioning from a moral, political, social, and legal point of view;4)have the ability to integrate knowledge in an interdisciplinary way;5) be capable of a personal and original elaboration of the contents discussed.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento neuroethics-and-human-enhancement-0

Reasoning with data 2° anno · 6 CFU · PHIL-02/A · 0 file

The course aims at developing the logico-mathematical background to assess critically the logic and epistemology of inductive reasoning, or "reasoning with data". In addition to making students familiar with the relevant…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course aims at developing the logico-mathematical background to assess critically the logic and epistemology of inductive reasoning, or "reasoning with data". In addition to making students familiar with the relevant elementary logical, probabilistic and statistical notions, it focusses on how the formalisation of inductive inference sheds crucial methodological light on the "datacentric" revolution, which is currently dotting the development of the natural and social sciences.

Knowledge acquisition and understanding:Students are expected to acquire a full understanding of the formal notions presented and master basic knowledge of the following topics:- know the central concepts and reasoning tools of discrete mathematics- know the central concepts in elementary probability theory- know how to apply elementary logic to formalize probabilistic concepts- understand the epistemological questions related to inductive reasoning- understand the relevance of a proper the epistemology of inductive inference in the wider methodological discussion on "big data"Skills acquisition and ability to apply knowledge:Students are also expected to develop an ability to apply this basic knowledge to solve simple problems and to engage in further research within more advanced projects in specific applications of their interest. In particular at the end of the course, students will be able to- read and evaluate the scientific literature on inductive reasoning- apply the tools learnt to solve scientific, philosophical and practical problems- appreciate the relevance of inductive logic in the current debate on the datacentric revolution in the methodology of the social sciences.

Programma

Knowledge acquisition and understanding:Students are expected to acquire a full understanding of the formal notions presented and master basic knowledge of the following topics:- know the central concepts and reasoning tools of discrete mathematics- know the central concepts in elementary probability theory- know how to apply elementary logic to formalize probabilistic concepts- understand the epistemological questions related to inductive reasoning- understand the relevance of a proper the epistemology of inductive inference in the wider methodological discussion on "big data"Skills acquisition and ability to apply knowledge:Students are also expected to develop an ability to apply this basic knowledge to solve simple problems and to engage in further research within more advanced projects in specific applications of their interest. In particular at the end of the course, students will be able to- read and evaluate the scientific literature on inductive reasoning- apply the tools learnt to solve scientific, philosophical and practical problems- appreciate the relevance of inductive logic in the current debate on the datacentric revolution in the methodology of the social sciences.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento reasoning-data-0

The welfare state and social innovation 2° anno · 6 CFU · GSPS-02/A · 0 file

The course provides students with the tools for the political understanding of recent transformation of the welfare state in terms of social innovation and welfare mix. For almost three decades, European countries have…

Scheda dell'insegnamento

Obiettivi formativi

The course provides students with the tools for the political understanding of recent transformation of the welfare state in terms of social innovation and welfare mix. For almost three decades, European countries have been striving to reform their social models, tailored on increasingly surpassed economic, socio-demographic and cultural structures. Reforms introduced at the national level, largely focused on the large programs of social protection, do not exhaust the array of ongoing transformations. In order to understand the breadth and nature of changes, this course moves beyond the perimeter of the public sector, directing attention towards recent developments in the market as well as in the third sector and civil society, and especially towards those new forms of intertwinement, collaboration and synergy that have been emerging between these two spheres (and often between them and the public sector) in welfare provision.

Students who attend the course will be able to address the issue of why different countries implement different social measures and policies, especially in times of crisis and in terms of social innovation; explore important concepts in the field of comparative social policy, including social citizenship, risk sharing, de-commodification, welfare mix, public-private partnership, social innovation, social investment; examine the forces driving welfare regimes' development in Western nations; analyze contemporary policy issues affecting Western welfare states, including globalization, demographic aging, labor market instability, gender equality, vulnerability and social exclusion, migration, populism; envisage the social and economic consequences of processes of welfare state crisis and the emergence of the "second welfare" paradigm; identify different approaches to explaining institutional variety in advanced welfare systems; examine the relevance of tools and frameworks for the study of Western welfare states and their recent transformation.

Programma

Students who attend the course will be able to address the issue of why different countries implement different social measures and policies, especially in times of crisis and in terms of social innovation; explore important concepts in the field of comparative social policy, including social citizenship, risk sharing, de-commodification, welfare mix, public-private partnership, social innovation, social investment; examine the forces driving welfare regimes' development in Western nations; analyze contemporary policy issues affecting Western welfare states, including globalization, demographic aging, labor market instability, gender equality, vulnerability and social exclusion, migration, populism; envisage the social and economic consequences of processes of welfare state crisis and the emergence of the "second welfare" paradigm; identify different approaches to explaining institutional variety in advanced welfare systems; examine the relevance of tools and frameworks for the study of Western welfare states and their recent transformation.

Modalità d'esame

Modalità di valutazione: EsameGiudizio di valutazione: voto verbalizzato in trentesimi

Codice insegnamento welfare-state-and-social-innovation-2

Recensioni del corso

Studi qui? Accedi per lasciare la tua recensione e aiutare altri studenti a scegliere.

★

Nessuna recensione per ora — e la prima è la più preziosa. Condividi la tua esperienza e orienta le future matricole.