The main goal of the course is to make the student able to navigate competently the long-standing debates on the role of 'culture' in the theory and practices of the social sciences. A related goal is to make the student able to choose for himself/herself the theoretical stances on these key debates. To 'choose' in this context implies having a sufficient understanding of the stakes involved, sufficient knowledge of the main positions in the debate, and the ability to justify one's theoretical preferences in the light of alternatives. A third goal is to document how sociologists can learn – and bring new perspectives – to important debates across the sciences. Far from restricting our attention to the sociological literature, in this class students will discuss texts originating in anthropology, primatology, artificial intelligence, evolutionary psychology and many other fields. The course will also provide the student with an occasion to exercise a set of skills that are crucial for any graduate student: reading closely and carefully a variety of different (sometimes difficult) texts, analyzing a variety of theoretical standpoints, and debating honestly and cunningly in class.
Culture is one of the most used (and abused) concepts in the social sciences. It has been repeatedly declared dead. It has been 'rediscovered'. It has been blamed and worshipped. The temptation to proclaim that everything is 'cultural' is at least as strong as the proclamation that everything is ‘social’. Already in the early '50s, a scholar had surveyed more than 56 different usages of the word 'culture' in the social sciences. They are likely to be many more now. The class will explore a small number of big issues concerning cultural analysis in the social sciences. After a short introduction, each week will be devoted to one of these issues, and precisely to the following ones: 1. Why Should Social Scientists Study Culture? 2. Is Culture a Human Specialty? I - What's about the other animals? 3. Is Culture a Human Specialty II? - Can Humans and Machines Share a Culture? 3. When Did Culture Start? 4. How Different are We from our Ancestors? Are we Really ‘Modern’? and what is ‘Modernity’ anyway? 5. Are There Universal Cultural Trends? 6 Is the Whole World Country? 7. What's the Problem with Identity? 8. How Institutions Think? 9. Are Cultural Structures Compatible with Our Brains? 10. Has Culture Something to Say about the Self? 11. Do Sociologists need culture?
The whole class is based on three simple operations: (a) reading seriously, (b) using the imagination, and (c) being willing to participate in class. All three operations are key to any meaningful experience as a student enrolled in an MA program. The whole class is built on these three operations, and all students willing to use them - no matter their background, linguistic competencies, etc. - are welcome. All students will be expected to have read (read, not glanced) in ADVANCE the text for the week. Their knowledge of the text will be TESTED weekly, at the very beginning, to ensure that 'reading in advance' means, well, reading in advance. Students who are not interested in reading the assigned reading weekly may well consider choosing another class or taking the exam as a non-attending student. In other words, attending students are students who read the texts in advance. Each week is unit-defined (see above) by a big question. Students will be repeatedly asked to use their own imagination to make use of the information and arguments they have read. Nearly all the chosen texts, moreover, are controversial. I will not introduce any 'right' interpretation of the texts, nor will I claim there is always one. I expect MA students to be willing to find their way out of the maze. While there is no problem with mistakes, even huge mistakes, all students must realize that relying on received views and adopting ideological sloganeering is just a waste of time, for them, their colleagues, and, unfortunately, their teacher. As students' opinion will be likely - and hopefully - very diverse, there will be ample room for debates. Reading the texts in advance is key to active participation in class. Most of the work in the classroom will be consequently active. The instructor will have no problem in directly asking those who do not intervene enough to do so (as well as saying to those who intervene too much to slow down). At the end of each week, there will be a short, very short, introduction to the reading for the subsequent week. It is important that all students join the Moodle of the course. It will be a major conduit of materials, information and – hopefully – debate. P.S. I keep reading in the students' evaluations that I assign 'too much'. Besides the fact that reading is never too much, the required readings are scrupulously within the boundaries of what can be assigned for an MA course.
Grades should not be the goal of a student. Learning should. Still, for some strange reasons, students worry about grades. So here are the rules: ATTENDING STUDENTS - Attending students will be assessed throughout the course AND with a (reduced) final written exam. At the beginning of each week, attending students will have to do a relatively simple test based on the weekly readings. Each positive test will count for up to 2 points. It is important to note that the tests will not be graded weekly but every four weeks or so. Participation in class and effort in classroom debates will provide up to 2 extra points. Attending students will also have to pass a special final exam composed of 3 open questions related to the required readings (particularly, but not exclusively, those they missed in weekly tests). Students are required to answer all questions at least sufficiently. Incomplete texts will be judged as insufficient or, in extraordinary cases, merely sufficient (pass). The answers will be evaluated according to the knowledge of the topic, the quality of the analysis, the integration of different sources, and the clarity of the style. N. B. A student will be considered 'attending' if he/she participates in classroom work (and tests) for at least 9 of the 12 weeks of the class (and if he or she has taken a large majority of the weekly tests). Exceptions may be granted for extraordinary reasons to be agreed upon in advance. NON-ATTENDING STUDENTS - Non-attending students will have to pass a two-hour-long written exam composed of 6 open questions related to the required readings. Questions will be designed to evaluate how the students have read, analyzed and thought about the texts, thus achieving the learning goals set for the course. Students are required to answer all six questions at least sufficiently. Incomplete texts will be judged usually insufficient or, in extraordinary cases, merely sufficient (pass). The answers will be evaluated according to the knowledge of the topic, the quality of the analysis, the integration of different sources, and the clarity of the style. All students – Attending and non-attending are required to join the classroom Moodle, as a great deal of information will be transmitted through it. The teacher is willing to provide the following supporting actions for non-attending students: Advice on further books and/or papers that may be useful to read to prepare adequately. Under no condition does the teacher provide videos, synchronous or asynchronous. It is also stressed that, although such rules may appear severe, most students, both attending and non-attending, have been able, provided they studied enough, to get quite good grades.
Two premises: 1. What does ‘reading’ means? The sociologist Harvey Luskin Molotch famously stated that "unless sociologists really do lead rich lives, engage the world, or at least read widely, their research and writing are emaciated.". I have serious doubts (academic) sociologists may ever lead rich lives, and I fear sociologists when they engage with the world. Moloch, however, is right on his third requirement. If you do not read widely and seriously, you are not a student because you are not studying, is not it? Another person, Joe Queenan has said it much better and more precisely (perhaps because he is not a sociologist): “Those who read seriously] do not primarily read to extract information, or to while away the time or to better themselves. They do not even read in order to know they are not alone. They read to escape to a more exciting, more rewarding world. A world where they do not hate their jobs, their spouses, their governments, their lives». This is the way the texts for this class should be read. 2. Required and Suggested Readings Each of the class units is based on one, sometimes two, compulsory reading(s). Whatever follows “If you really like this stuff…” is useful and important, but not compulsory. To avoid misunderstanding, I marked with a C all compulsory readings. Readings marked with * require more time and focus than usual. A good idea is to set aside more time to read, think and re-read them. They require more effort, but they bring more rewards. 1. Why Should Social Scientists Study Culture? C. Talcott Parsons, 1968, ‘Interaction. Social Interaction’ In David L. Sills (ed.), International Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. Macmillan. Vol. 7, pp. 429-440 (1968) * If you really like this stuff, you may want to read also: Jon Elster, 1989, The Two Problems of Social Order, pp.1-16 in his The Cement of Society, Cambridge UP. 2. Is Culture a Human Specialty? I - What's about the other animals? C. McGrew, William Clement. The Cultured Chimpanzee: Reflections on Cultural Primatology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004, the choice of chapters will be posted in Moodle If you are interested in this stuff, you may want to read the whole book. To discover the enduring significance of primates in social theory, you may want to also read the following: Langlitz, Nicolas. "Primatology of science: On the birth of Actor-Network Theory from baboon field observations." Theory, Culture & Society 36.1 (2019): 83-105. 3. Is Culture a Human Specialty II? - Can Humans and Machines Share a Culture? C. Turing, Alan M. "Computing machinery and intelligence (1950)." Mind 59.236 (2021): 33-60. if you really like this stuff, you may want to read also Searle, John R. "Minds, brains, and programs." Behavioral and brain sciences 3.3 (1980): 417-424. 4. When Did Culture Start? C. Massey, D. S. (2002). "A Brief History of Human Society: The Origin and Role of Emotion in Social Life." American Sociological Review 67(1): 1-29. If you really like this stuff, you may want to read: Gwenn Rigal, 2016, Le temps sacré des cavernes : De Chauvet à Lascaux, les hypothèses de la science, Paris: Corti [Italian translation, Adelphi, 2022; surprisingly, there is no English translation] Robert N. Bellah, 2011, Religion in Human Evolution, Harvard University Press, chap. 1, 2 and 3. 5. How Different are We from our Ancestors? Are we Really ‘Modern’? and what is ‘Modernity’ anyway? C. E. Gellner, 1988, Plough, Sword and Book. The Structure of Human History, The University of Chicago Press, the choice of chapters will be posted in Moodle If you are interested in this stuff, you may want to read the whole book. And may be also Jack Goody, 1977, The Domestication of the Savage Mind. Cambridge University Press. 6. Are There Universal Cultural Trends? C. Max Weber, Author’s Introduction, in Max Weber, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Routledge 2001, pp. xxviii- xlii. Beware the text does not belong properly to The Protestant Ethic. It was written for another book. Several editions of The Protestant Ethic do not include it. Look for one that does. If you are interested in this stuff, you may want to read what is (in my opinion) one of the very few masterpieces of the whole social sciences. That is, the very few pages Max Weber wrote, in a hurry, as an interlude to his monstrous-sized comparative sociology of religion. See M. Weber, “Religious Rejections of the World and Their Directions”, in Geerth and Mills, From Max Weber, Oxford UP, 1946, pp. 323-362. 7. Is the Whole World Country? C. Henrich, J., Heine, S., & Norenzayan, A. (2010). The Weirdest People in the World? Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 33(2-3), 61-83. doi:10.1017/S0140525X0999152X 2. If you really like this stuff, you may want to read: Henrich, Joseph. The WEIRDest people in the world: How the West became psychologically peculiar and particularly prosperous. Penguin UK, 2020. Apicella, Coren, Ara Norenzayan, and Joseph Henrich. "Beyond WEIRD: A review of the last decade and a look ahead to the global laboratory of the future." Evolution and Human Behavior 41.5 (2020): 319-329. 8. What's the Problem with Identity? C. Brubaker, Rogers, and Frederick Cooper. “Beyond ‘Identity.’” Theory and Society, vol. 29, no. 1, 2000, pp. 1–47. if you really like this stuff, you should definitely read: Chang-Zunino, Mia, and Stine Grodal. "Junkies, queers, and babies: Persistence and updating of the category AIDS through silencing and puncturing of the moral boundary." Administrative Science Quarterly 69.3 (2024): 571-618. Marjorie Rhodes and Andrew Baron, 2019, The Development of Social Categorization, Annual Review of Developmental Psychology 1:1, 359-386. John Levi Martin, 2000, What do animals do all day? The division of labor, class bodies, and totemic thinking in the popular imagination, Poetics, Volume 27, Issues 2–3, Pages 195-231. 9. How Institutions Think? C. Douglas, Mary. How institutions think. Syracuse University Press, 1986. if you really like this stuff, everything written by Mary Douglas is worth reading 10. Has Culture Something to Say about the Self? C. Hacking, Ian. "Making up people." Forms of desire. Routledge, 2013. 69-88. If you really like this stuff, you should also read: Brubaker, R. , Gender Identity: The Career of a Category, “Theory and Social Inquiry“, https://doi.org/10.16995/tsi.18211 Lukes, Steven. "Durkheim's ‘individualism and the intellectuals’." Political Studies 17.1 (1969): 14-30. 11. Do Sociologists need culture? C. N. Luhmann, Kultur als historischer Begriff, in N. Luhmann, 1995, Gesellschaftstrukture und semantik, Band 4, Suhrkamp Verlag. English translation in Culture as an Historical Concept, pp. 300-319 in N. Luhmann, The Making of Meaning, Oxford, 2022.