principles of criminal law
Di cosa parla
Riassunto AI · si legge in un minuto
Leggi il riassunto completo
- What is Criminal Law and Punishment?
- Criminal law deals with crimes, which are offenses punishable by criminal sanction.
- Punishment involves the infliction of suffering, a loss of freedom, or financial penalties by the state, distinct from compensation.
- Criminal law is primarily national, but international criminal law and human rights frameworks (e.g., EU law, ECHR) significantly impact national systems.
- Theories of Punishment:
- Retributivism (Absolute Theories): Punishment is justified because a crime was committed ('punitur quia peccatum est'). It is backward-looking.
- Key concepts: 'Just desert,' 'lex taliones' (an eye for an eye).
- Types: Divine, Moral (Kant: compensates ethical principle violation), Legal (Hegel: reaffirms legal order).
- Arguments: Free will, paying back debt to society, addressing unfair advantages.
- Limits: Personality of criminal liability (punish only the guilty), Proportionality (punishment fits the crime).
- Criticisms: Morality's subjectivity, lack of consensus on 'just' punishment, state's role in enforcing morality.
- Preventive Theories (Relative Theories): Punishment is justified by its purpose of preventing future crimes ('punitur ne peccetur'). It is forward-looking.
- Utilitarianism (Bentham): Maximize overall societal happiness/utility. Punishment is an instrument to prevent future crimes.
- Deterrence: Rational individuals weigh pain vs. pleasure.
- General deterrence: Deters others in society by example.
- Specific deterrence: Deters the offender from re-offending.
- Criticisms: Ethical concerns (treating individuals as means), potential for disproportionate punishment, empirical doubts (certainty of punishment is more effective than severity).
- Positive General Prevention: Educates citizens on societal values.
- Special Prevention: Focuses on the individual offender.
- Positive Special Prevention (Rehabilitation): Aims to restore the criminal, making them a good citizen. Requires measures beyond incarceration.
- Negative Special Prevention (Incapacitation): Physically prevents the offender from committing crimes (e.g., imprisonment).
- Criticisms: Rehabilitation's effectiveness is debated; incapacitation can lead to indeterminate sentences and proportionality issues; moral objections regarding individual autonomy.
- Utilitarianism (Bentham): Maximize overall societal happiness/utility. Punishment is an instrument to prevent future crimes.
- Restorative Justice: Moves away from punishment, focusing on victim compensation and re-establishing dialogue between offender and victim.
- Retributivism (Absolute Theories): Punishment is justified because a crime was committed ('punitur quia peccatum est'). It is backward-looking.
- Polyfunctionality of Punishment:
- Many scholars believe punishment serves multiple purposes simultaneously (e.g., Italian Constitution Art. 27: rehabilitation).
- Different purposes may dominate at various stages: deterrence (threat stage), special prevention/rehabilitation (sentencing and enforcement stages).
- Principles Limiting the State's Power to Impose Penalties:
- Proportionality: Punishment must be proportionate to the crime's seriousness and offender's culpability (Art. 49 European Charter of Fundamental Rights).
- Prohibition of Inhuman and Degrading Punishments (Art. 3 ECHR): Absolute guarantee against torture, inhuman, or degrading treatment (e.g., prison overcrowding, solitary confinement).
- Prohibition of Capital Punishment: Abolished in most Council of Europe states (Protocols 6 & 13 ECHR). ECHR jurisprudence regards extradition to countries with death penalty as a potential violation of Art. 3.
- Life Imprisonment: Considered a violation of Art. 3 ECHR if it is 'irreducible' (no prospect of release) or 'grossly disproportionate' (Vinter and Others v. UK). The Italian 'ergastolo ostativo' (life without parole for non-cooperating mafia members) was found to violate Art. 3 (Viola v. Italy).
- Theories of Criminalization:
- Mala in se vs. Mala quia prohibita: Distinguishes inherently wrong acts from acts wrong only because prohibited by law.
- Continental European Tradition (Legal Goods): Criminal law should only protect 'legal goods' (socially relevant interests). This acts as a limit to state power and influenced the 'offensiveness principle' in Italy.
- Anglo-American Tradition (Harm Principle - John Stuart Mill): Criminalization is justified only when conduct causes 'serious harm' to individuals or creates a serious risk of harm.
- Offence Principle (Feinberg): Supplements the harm principle, allowing criminalization of acts causing 'offence' or strong negative feelings, though criticized for subjectivity.
- Paternalism: Debates whether acts harming oneself (e.g., drug use) should be criminalized.
- Hard paternalism: Protects capable adults against their will (criticized for violating autonomy).
- Soft paternalism: Intervenes only when conduct is not substantially voluntary, protecting rational choices from external factors.
- Legal Moralism: Criminalizes acts considered immoral. Criticized for subjectivity ('straight moralism') or justified if safeguarding shared societal values ('functional moralism').
Riassunto generato con l'intelligenza artificiale a partire dagli appunti. Come lo facciamo
Stai vedendo l'anteprima delle prime pagine. Il file completo è gratis: registrati per leggerlo tutto.
Studia questi appunti con l'AI
Riassunto e domande d'esame sono gratis: chiedili e ti mandiamo un'email quando sono pronti.
In preparazione: di solito è pronto in giornata.
Questo appunto è gratis. Registrati in 30 secondi per leggere tutte le pagine e scaricarlo.
Simula l'esame con domande costruite su questi appunti.
Ripassa l'esame di PRINCIPLES OF CRIMINAL LAW
20 carte di ripasso sul programma ufficiale dell'insegnamento. Prova le prime:
Che cosa si intende per principio di complementarità nel diritto penale internazionale e quale ruolo assegna agli Stati? Gira la carta
Che cos'è il margine nazionale di apprezzamento e in quale ambito è elaborato? Gira la carta
Perché la giurisprudenza ha un ruolo cruciale nella produzione della norma penale applicabile in un contesto multilivello? Gira la carta
Carte generate con l'intelligenza artificiale dal programma dell'insegnamento: possono contenere errori.
Di cosa parla l'insegnamento
PRINCIPLES OF CRIMINAL LAW · 2° anno · 6 CFU · IUS/17
L’obiettivo del corso è fornire la conoscenza, in prospettiva comparata e internazionale, del sistema penale, delle profonde mutazioni introdotte dal processo di internazionalizzazione ed europeizzazione e della importanza della comparazione dei principi costituzionali e dei concetti fondamentali del diritto penale;…