Altro VERIFICATO
Towards a Theory of Property Rights
64 visualizzazioni
102 download
★ 3,5 (2)
Di cosa parla
- Definition and Role of Property Rights:
- Property rights are a social construct that establishes expectations regarding dealings with others.
- They define how individuals can benefit or harm themselves and others, and who must compensate for modifying actions.
- A key concept is the intrinsic link between property rights and externalities.
- Understanding Externalities:
- An externality occurs when the cost of internalizing a beneficial or harmful effect (i.e., bringing it to bear on economic decisions) is too high relative to the gains.
- The primary function of property rights is to guide incentives towards a greater internalization of these externalities, leading to more efficient resource use.
- Examples, such as slave labor or the military draft, illustrate how prohibiting property rights adjustments (like the right to freedom or exemption) creates externalities by increasing transaction costs.
- Emergence of Property Rights:
- Property rights emerge when it becomes economically beneficial to internalize externalities, typically in response to new or changing beneficial and harmful effects.
- This emergence is driven by changes in knowledge, production functions, market values, technology, and relative prices.
- Historical examples include the development of private land rights among American Indians in the Labrador Peninsula, directly linked to the commercial fur trade. The increased value of furs made it economic to "husband" fur-bearing animals, necessitating rights to prevent poaching.
- In contrast, such rights did not emerge among Southwestern Plains Indians due to different animal habits (grazing over wide areas) and lack of commercial value, making internalization costs outweigh benefits.
- Coalescence and Ownership Structures:
- The paper distinguishes between communal, private, and state ownership.
- Communal ownership, where rights are shared by all, often leads to "great externalities" because individual costs are not concentrated on the actor, resulting in overexploitation (e.g., overhunting, overworking land). High negotiation and policing costs make agreements difficult, and future generations' claims are not effectively represented.
- Private ownership internalizes many external costs by allowing owners to exclude others and directly realize benefits and costs. This creates strong incentives for efficient resource management.
- A key advantage of private ownership is the significant reduction in negotiation costs for remaining externalities, as fewer parties (often only those directly affected) need to agree, unlike communal systems where universal agreement might be required.
- Modern Applications and Legal Modifications:
- The framework is extended to understand the structure of the modern corporation.
- Large-scale operations with many capital providers lead to the need for joint-stock companies.
- To mitigate high negotiation costs if all owners participate, authority is delegated to management (de facto owners).
- Further legal modifications, like limited liability and the ability to easily trade shares (the "escape hatch"), minimize externalities for shareholders, making it easier to raise equity capital and aligning management incentives.
- The principles also apply to intellectual property, like copyrights and patents, which grant private rights to incentivize innovation by internalizing benefits, even while acknowledging that externalities (e.g., making old ideas obsolete) still exist but can be managed through market negotiations.