Appunti VERIFICATO

Theories of Punishment

Università degli Studi di Torino global law and transnational legal studies 2022
247 visualizzazioni
33 download
★ 4,5 (1)
Condividi: WhatsApp Telegram

Di cosa parla

Riassunto AI · si legge in un minuto

This document explores theories of punishment, contrasting instrumentalism (utilitarian, forward-looking, focused on deterrence, rehabilitation, prevention) with retributivism (backward-looking, based on "desert" for committed crimes, emphasized by Kant and Hegel). Instrumentalism, despite aiming for positive effects, faces criticism for potentially dehumanizing offenders and causing injustice by treating them as means to an end. Retributivism, justifying punishment as a consequence of free choice and law-breaking, is criticized for its difficulty in defining proportional "desert" and its potential for institutionalized revenge driven by emotions rather than pure rationality. A critical perspective reveals that modern criminal justice systems often fail to apply principles of equality and dignity, exhibiting unfairness, discrimination, and a flawed reliance on the "free will" concept, particularly highlighted by feminist and critical legal studies regarding issues like domestic violence and mass incarceration. Despite these flaws, there's growing awareness of human rights and efforts toward social justice.
Leggi il riassunto completo
  • The document examines two primary theories of punishment: Instrumentalism (Utilitarianism) and Retributivism.
  • Instrumentalism justifies punishment by its anticipated positive effects, such as re-education, rehabilitation, and deterrence. It encompasses:
    • Preventive strategies: Removing dangerous individuals from society.
    • Deterrence: Using punishment as a threat to reduce crimes, both specific (reducing recidivism) and general (reducing overall crime).
    • Rehabilitation practices: Promoting the reintegration of offenders.
    However, instrumentalism is criticized for:
    • Not punishing according to 'desert,' potentially leading to disproportionate sentences.
    • Treating offenders as a means to an end, thus dehumanizing them (a key critique from Immanuel Kant).
    • The risk of injustice and unlimited suffering for individuals and minorities in the pursuit of social goals.
  • Retributivism justifies punishment retrospectively, based on the crime committed and the offender's decision to break the law. Key proponents include:
    • Hegel: Punishment nullifies the crime, serving as a retribution that 'disappears' the offense morally and legally, emphasizing proportionality.
    • Kant: Argues punishment is deserved due to free choice, but must respect human dignity and impose limits on violence.
    Criticisms against retributivism include:
    • Its moral status, questioning if it's an alternative to revenge or merely institutionalized revenge.
    • Difficulty in defining 'intelligibility' and 'proportionality' – what exact punishment a crime 'deserves.'
    • The influence of emotions, rather than pure rationality, in determining social reactions to crimes.
  • A Critical Perspective on Criminal Justice and Punishment highlights practical discrepancies:
    • Empirical research reveals significant unfairness in trial procedures and discrimination against women and ethnic minorities.
    • The 'ideology of equality' often conflicts with concrete practices, serving as an instrument of oppression.
    • The Enlightenment liberal idea of the 'mens rea' (free rational agent) is challenged, positing that individuals have 'limited rationality' and are influenced by social context.
    • The prison system, viewed as 'total institutions' (Erving Goffman), often fails to rehabilitate offenders, leading to high recidivism and human rights violations.
    • Feminist critique underscores how legal systems reflect male perspectives, leading to 'formal equality' that perpetuates 'concrete injustice,' particularly in cases of domestic violence and rape where victims are often re-victimized by the system.
    • Despite these deep-seated issues, there's a growing international awareness of human rights and ongoing efforts to promote social justice and rights for minorities.

Riassunto generato con l'intelligenza artificiale a partire dagli appunti. Come lo facciamo

Anteprima pagina 1 — Theories of Punishment Anteprima pagina 2 — Theories of Punishment Anteprima pagina 3 — Theories of Punishment

Stai vedendo l'anteprima delle prime pagine. Il file completo è gratis: registrati per leggerlo tutto.

Studia questi appunti con l'AI

Riassunto e domande d'esame sono gratis: chiedili e ti mandiamo un'email quando sono pronti.

Questo appunto è gratis. Registrati in 30 secondi per leggere tutte le pagine e scaricarlo.

Simula l'esame con domande costruite su questi appunti.

Di cosa parla l'insegnamento

PHILOSOPHY OF LAW · 1° anno · 9 CFU · GIUR-17/A

The course aims to provide students with basic knowledge and elements of legal philosophy and jurisprudence. Furthermore, we aim to enable students to develop arguments and critical reflections on the main subjects of the course as well as to make a correct use of the philosophical and legal language. The course aims…

Scheda completa nella pagina del corso

Altri appunti di PHILOSOPHY OF LAW

Condividi questi appunti

WhatsApp Telegram